chessgames.com
Members · Prefs · Laboratory · Collections · Openings · Endgames · Sacrifices · History · Search Kibitzing · Kibitzer's Café · Chessforums · Tournament Index · Players · Kibitzing

Vladimir Petrov
Petrov 
 

Number of games in database: 346
Years covered: 1922 to 1942
Overall record: +163 -78 =102 (62.4%)*
   * Overall winning percentage = (wins+draws/2) / total games in the database. 3 exhibition games, blitz/rapid, odds games, etc. are excluded from this statistic.

MOST PLAYED OPENINGS
With the White pieces:
 Queen's Pawn Game (20) 
    D02 D04 D05 E00 A40
 Catalan (16) 
    E02 E01 E06
 Sicilian (16) 
    B58 B29 B40 B74 B25
 Slav (15) 
    D17 D15 D12 D13 D18
 Orthodox Defense (11) 
    D52 D64 D63 D60 D65
 King's Indian (10) 
    E60 E67
With the Black pieces:
 Sicilian (30) 
    B74 B56 B80 B72 B84
 French Defense (22) 
    C10 C01 C17 C14 C11
 Queen's Pawn Game (20) 
    D02 D04 A45 A40 A46
 Slav (14) 
    D19 D10 D15 D18 D13
 Sicilian Dragon (11) 
    B74 B72 B73 B70
 French (9) 
    C10 C11 C13 C00
Repertoire Explorer

NOTABLE GAMES: [what is this?]
   Petrov vs R Grau, 1939 1-0
   Stahlberg vs Petrov, 1938 0-1
   L Rellstab vs Petrov, 1937 0-1
   Petrov vs Alekhine, 1938 1-0
   G Page vs Petrov, 1933 0-1
   Petrov vs I Strazdins, 1926 1-0
   J Turn vs Petrov, 1929 0-1
   Petrov vs T Bergs, 1929 1-0
   K Richter vs Petrov, 1936 1/2-1/2
   Petrov vs Stahlberg, 1937 1-0

NOTABLE TOURNAMENTS: [what is this?]
   Rosario (1939)
   Kemeri (1937)
   Margate (1938)
   Lodz (1938)
   non-FIDE Munich Olympiad (1936)
   Buenos Aires Olympiad Final-A (1939)
   Hamburg Olympiad (1930)
   Moravska Ostrava (1933)
   Kemeri (1939)
   Stockholm Olympiad (1937)
   Podebrady (1936)
   USSR Championship (1940)
   Prague Olympiad (1931)
   Warsaw Olympiad (1935)
   Folkestone Olympiad (1933)

GAME COLLECTIONS: [what is this?]
   Vladimirs Petrovs Tournaments/Matches 1923-1942 by jessicafischerqueen
   Vladimirs Petrovs Chess Biography by jessicafischerqueen
   Hero of the Pre-War Olympiads, GM Vladimirs Petr by nizmo11
   Buenos Aires Olympiad 1939 (Petrov's games) by jessicafischerqueen
   Stockholm Olympiad 1937 (Petrov's games) by jessicafischerqueen
   Lodz 1938 by jessicafischerqueen
   Kemeri 1939 by jessicafischerqueen
   Kemeri 1939 by plerranov
   Warsaw Olympiad 1935 (Petrov's games) by jessicafischerqueen
   Munich Unofficial Olympiad 1936 (Petrovs' games) by jessicafischerqueen
   Sverdlovsk 1942 National Tournament by jessicafischerqueen
   3rd Latvian Chess Congress 1930-1931 by jessicafischerqueen
   Bad Harzburg 1938 by jessicafischerqueen


Search Sacrifice Explorer for Vladimir Petrov
Search Google for Vladimir Petrov

VLADIMIR PETROV
(born Sep-27-1907, died Aug-26-1943, 35 years old) Latvia

[what is this?]

Vladimir Petrov (Latvian spelling: Vladimirs Petrovs) was born in Riga, Latvia, on 27th September 1907 (some sources list 1908 as the birth year).* Although he joined the ranks of the world chess elite in 1937, he is perhaps less well known than he should be, due to his being arrested by the NKVD in 1942 and imprisoned for the rest of his life.(1) He was subsequently expunged from Soviet chess history. Most of Petrov's colleagues in the Soviet bloc, with the notable exceptions of Alexander Koblents and Paul Keres, avoided publishing his games, or even mentioning his name in public.(2) Consequently, little was heard about Petrov in the west until long after his career and life had ended. The political turmoil of the USSR kept him from being as well known as he deserved. He notched a lifetime 50% score against both Alexander Alekhine and Jose Raul Capablanca, and defeated an impressive list of international masters including Alekhine, Keres, Samuel Reshevsky, Reuben Fine, Rudolf Spielmann, Isaac Boleslavsky, Gideon Stahlberg, Savielly Tartakower, Grigory Levenfish, Erich Eliskases, Vladas Mikenas, Karel Treybal, Georgy Lisitsin, Vladimir Makogonov, and Alexander Kotov.

Genesis of a Master

Petrov's father ran a modest cobbler's shop in Riga, while his mother worked as a housekeeper. In 1919, Petrov was accepted at the prestigious Lomonosov High School, where he received a first rate liberal arts education. In that same year, the streets of Riga were barricaded as nationalists fought Bolshevik and German armies to retain Latvian independence, which had been declared in 1918. Such concerns seemed far from Petrov's mind, however, as he enjoyed a vibrant school life centered largely around music, soccer, and gambling at cards with his friends. He and his friends grew bored with cards, and were introduced to chess by Viktors Rosenbergs , who offered to help hone their skills. Petrov soon challenged him to a 100 game chess match, which he ultimately won. In 1923, he won the school championship and joined the Riga-2 chess club, and a year later went on to win the reserves section of the first Latvian Chess Congress, earning the first category title. His optimism and spark in almost everything he tried earned him the nickname "Successful like Petka," and he was indeed successful in gaining admission to the Riga School of Jurisprudence in 1925, although he would not graduate for another 16 years. In 1926, he won the strong Riga City Championship, which prompted him to devote almost all of his time to a quest to become a chess master.

Chess Olympian

Setting law books aside, Petrov instead immersed himself in the games of Latvia's strongest players, Hermanis Mattison and Fricis Apsenieks. In his own games, he favored Mattisons' positional style, and soon became an expert at knowing exactly when to trade down to a winning endgame, a characteristic he would retain throughout his career. His star rose quickly as he finished shared second in the 1926 Latvian Chess Congress, and earned his Latvian master title by winning the 1930-1931 Latvian Chess Congress. Petrov played third board for Latvia at the inaugural FIDE Chess Olympiad at The Hague 1928, and went on to play for Latvia in all the Chess Olympiads up to 1939, garnering a gold medal on third board at Prague 1931, and a bronze medal on first board at Buenos Aires 1939. He won his first Latvian Championship in 1930, and tied with Apsenieks in the 1934 edition. Petrov had his heart set on playing first board for the Olympic team, so instead of a playoff match to decide the Latvian championship, Petrov struck a deal with Apsenieks: he would concede the title in exchange for first board in all subsequent Chess Olympiads.

Joining the Elite

Petrov won another Latvian championship in 1935, and gave a creditable performance on first board at the Warsaw 1935 Olympiad, scoring 55% and defeating both the Lithuanian and Argentine champions, Vladas Mikenas and Roberto Grau. On the strength of these results, Petrov was invited to his first major international tournament, the Czech Championship in Podebrady (1936). Despite a disappointing 10th place finish, Petrov was included in another top event, this time in his home city of Riga. At Kemeri (1937) he stunned the chess world by finishing shared first with Reshevsky and Salomon Flohr, ahead of both Alekhine and Keres. Reshevsky and Flohr decided that it was most fitting that Petrov should accept the tournament prize from Latvian president Karlis Ulmanis. In addition, he was awarded a silver cup donated by the Aron Nimzowitsch family, honoring the "best result by a Latvian against a foreign master" for this brilliancy with the black pieces- L Rellstab vs Petrov, 1937. Petrov also earned the title of Grandmaster, due to a widely recognized convention in European chess at this time that if a home town player won a tournament in which at least six foreign Grandmasters participated, then that player would also be recognized as a Grandmaster. Petrov's surprise victory at Kemeri created a stir among European chess journals, which then began referring to him as a "Latvian Grandmaster."(3) He also received laudatory notices from prominent peers such as Max Euwe, Emanuel Lasker and Alexander Alekhine.

More invitations to premier events were forthcoming, but Petrov lacked consistency at the top level and he logged uneven international results from 1937-1939. He finished dead last at Semmering/Baden (1937) against a very tough field, featuring Capablanca, Keres, Fine, Reshevsky and Flohr. Petrov fared much better at Tallinn 1938 in the Latvia-Estonia team match, leading his side to victory by defeating Keres 1.5-.5 on first board. He then finished a respectable third at Margate (1938), surprising Alekhine by almost checkmating him in the middle of the board- Petrov vs Alekhine, 1938. After disappointing his Latvian fans with a dismal eighth place at Kemeri 1939, Petrov rebounded yet again with a bronze medal performance on first board at the Buenos Aires 1939 Olympiad. He scored 71% without losing a game, prompting Harry Golombek to remark "Petrov played the best chess at Buenos Aires."

Life as a Soviet Master

Shortly after a harrowing return journey from Buenos Aires through mine-filled seas, the Olympic bronze medalist was faced with a new challenge. Not only was Europe at war, but in 1940 the Soviet Union invaded Latvia and established a puppet communist government. No more would Latvia field Olympic teams, and Petrov was no longer allowed to participate as an organizer of Latvian chess events. At first, however, Petrov was guardedly optimistic about this upheaval. Although he had always been dubious and wary about the Bolshevik life in Russia, he and his wife Galina had long been members of what might be termed Latvia's Russian cultural intelligentsia. Though both considered themselves Latvian, they were steeped in Russian music, literature, theatre, and dance, and frequently attended such cultural events in Riga. Even better, after Latvia became the Latvian SSR (Latvian Soviet Socialist Republic), Petrov was awarded the title of Soviet master and seeded into the 12th USSR Championship (1940). Petrov did well to finish in the middle of the field, behind future world champions Mikhail Botvinnik and Vasily Smyslov, but ahead of Grigory Levenfish, who had won the 1937 USSR Championship, and Alexander Kotov, who had finished second in the 1939 Championship. In addition, he defeated both Levenfish and Kotov in their individual games. Petrov also drew both of the event's co-winners, Andre Lilienthal and Igor Bondarevsky.

On his return to Riga to rejoin his family and play in the inaugural Latvian Soviet Socialist Republic (SSR) Championship, Petrov found his wife worrying about the current Bolshevik regime. She reported that availability of food and other materials in Riga was already scarce, and even worse, local government purges and general deportations were well under way. Petrov, now employed by the Soviet TASS news agency, had experienced no particular trouble during his trip to Russia, and he tried to assuage her fears. Nonetheless, as he left again for the USSR Championship Semi-finals in Rostov-on-Don, she pressed a photo of herself and their child into his palm for "good luck." He never saw either of them again. After six rounds of the semi-finals had been completed, in Petrov's section only Alexander Tolush had a better score, and it seemed that he was destined to qualify for his second USSR Championship.(4) However, the Semi-final was abandoned on 23 June 1941 when news reached the tournament that the Germans had invaded the Soviet Union. There was a mad rush as the players attempted to reach home. Petrov, accompanied by Latvian chess colleagues Alexander Koblents and Janis Fride, was halted at a customs station near Abrene, in the Latvian district of Latgale. They were informed that they could travel no further, as the German army had already overrun Latvia. Petrov was forced to return to Moscow, but soon left for Gorky to volunteer in the Russian-Latvian Rifle Division. He was summoned back to Moscow in the winter of 1941, where he finished second to Isaak Mazel, ahead of Vasily Panov and Vladimir Alatortsev in the Moscow City Championship. Petrov then took a position as Assistant Commandant in the Moscow council "Dynamo," devoted to organizing logistics and defense in a city many feared would soon be under siege. Despite the German advance into the heart of Russia, however, the Soviet Chess Section still managed to keep organizing tournaments. At the Moscow national tournament in 1942 Petrov finished second behind Bondarevsky, ahead of Alatortsev, Mikenas, and Panov. Evacuated to Sverdlosk in 1942, Petrov competed in another national tournament, finishing second to Viacheslav Ragozin, ahead of Alexey Sokolsky, Boleslavsky, and Georgy Ilivitsky.

Gulag

Characteristically, Petrov had a habit of speaking frankly to friends and colleagues about his impressions of life in Soviet Latvia and Russia, some of which were critical of the Bolshevik regime. According to both Galina Petrova and Russian historian Sergey Voronkov, three fellow chess masters denounced Petrov to the authorities.(5) After Sverdlovsk, Vladas Mikenas recalls that he expected to see Petrov participate at the next major tournament in Kuibishev, but he never showed up. On August 31, 1942, Petrov was arrested and questioned for two weeks in Moscow at Lubyanka prison for violating "Article 58," a catch-all law that forbade any kind of anti-Soviet statements or activities. He was subsequently transferred to Moscow's notorious Butyrka jail for a further five months of detention and interrogation. On February 3, 1943 Petrov was sentenced to ten years in Vorkuta Gulag for criticizing decreased living standards in Latvia after the Soviet annexation of 1940. According to a death certificate released by the KGB in 1989, Petrov died of pneumonia in, or en route to, the gulag on August 26, 1943.(5)

Rehabilitation

Galina Petrova lost contact with her husband in 1942, and spent the rest of her life trying to find out what happened to him. Galina was given conflicting reports of his arrest and detention, so she moved to Siberia in an attempt to find any record he had been at a gulag. After Stalin's death in 1953, Nikita Khrushchev rehabilitated the names of thousands who had died during "The Terror," but the conviction against Petrov was upheld. It would not be until the era of Glasnost that Mikhail Gorbachev finally rehabilitated Vladimir Petrov's name, with an official pardon in March 1989.

Notes

(*) There are conflicting sources on the birth year of Vladimirs Petrovs. The Russian Wikipedia article, for example, gives *both* 1907 and 1908 as the birth year: Wikipedia article: Петров, Владимир Михайлович (шахматист) In the kibitzing section below, one can read a detailed account of which sources favor which birth year.

(1) The NKVD (Peoples Commissariat for Internal Affairs) was a predecessor of the KGB.

(2) Andris Fride <Vladimirs Petrovs: A Chessplayer's Story - From Greatness to the Gulags>, Caissa Editions, 2004.

(3) Vladimir Dedkov, ed. <Star Extinguished Before its Time> Riga, 2008

(4) At Rostov-on-Don 1941, the USSR Championship semifinal was organized into four separate sections. When the tournament abruptly ended, Petrov sat second in his section, a half point behind Tolush.

(5) Alexei Shirov, with Sergey Voronkov and Vladimir Dedkov <"Restoring the Annals of Latvian Chess History"> (ru) http://chess-news.ru/node/5341

Sources

Andris Fride <Vladimirs Petrovs: A Chessplayer's Story - From Greatness to the Gulags>, Caissa Editions, 2004.

Vladimir Dedkov, ed. <Star Extinguished Before its Time> Riga, 2008

Sergey Grodzensky <The Lubyanka Gambit>, Olympia Press, Moscow 2004

Alexei Shirov, with Sergey Voronkov and Vladimir Dedkov <"Restoring the Annals of Latvian Chess History"> (ru) http://chess-news.ru/node/5341

Biographical Game Collection

1.Game Collection: Vladimirs Petrovs Tournaments/Matches 1923-1942

Last updated: 2024-05-10 04:54:52

Try our new games table.

 page 1 of 14; games 1-25 of 346  PGN Download
Game  ResultMoves YearEvent/LocaleOpening
1. V Rosenbergs vs Petrov 1-0151922Blitz MatchB10 Caro-Kann
2. Petrov vs A Strautmanis ½-½381925Match Russian Secondary - City Gymnasium C80 Ruy Lopez, Open
3. H Mattison vs Petrov  ½-½441926Incognito Match Riga Ch.Club - Latvian Univ.B44 Sicilian
4. F Apsenieks vs Petrov  0-13919261st Riga ChampionshipB32 Sicilian
5. S Meiers vs Petrov  1-0641926Match Latvia Univ.-Liepaja Chess ClubB56 Sicilian
6. Petrov vs I Strazdins 1-02219262nd Latvian congressD60 Queen's Gambit Declined, Orthodox Defense
7. T Bergs vs Petrov  1-07219262nd Latvian congressA48 King's Indian
8. Petrov vs Udo Vitte 1-0241928Riga Chess Club championshipD52 Queen's Gambit Declined
9. N Elisons vs Petrov  1-0541928Riga Chess Club championshipA00 Uncommon Opening
10. Petrov vs J Turn  1-0641928Match Riga University - Tartu UniversityB02 Alekhine's Defense
11. M Feigin vs Petrov  0-1311928Olympic selection tournamentC14 French, Classical
12. Petrov vs K Makarczyk 1-0481928The Hague OlympiadD64 Queen's Gambit Declined, Orthodox, Rubinstein Attack
13. Petrov vs O Karlin  1-0361928The Hague OlympiadB40 Sicilian
14. Petrov vs J Rejfir  ½-½321928The Hague OlympiadD63 Queen's Gambit Declined, Orthodox Defense
15. Petrov vs W Schelfhout  ½-½261928The Hague OlympiadD92 Grunfeld, 5.Bf4
16. Petrov vs T Bergs 1-02819281st Reiner Cafe tE21 Nimzo-Indian, Three Knights
17. Petrov vs F Apsenieks  0-15519282nd Reiner Cafe tD43 Queen's Gambit Declined Semi-Slav
18. J Turn vs Petrov 0-1311929Match Tartu University - Riga UniversityD35 Queen's Gambit Declined
19. Petrov vs J Turn  ½-½651929Match Tartu University - Riga UniversityD52 Queen's Gambit Declined
20. Petrov vs T Bergs 1-02419293rd Reiner Cafe tB13 Caro-Kann, Exchange
21. Petrov vs Gerz Gladstein  1-03519291st Match Riga - KaunasD06 Queen's Gambit Declined
22. A Asgeirsson vs Petrov  0-1141930Hamburg OlympiadB56 Sicilian
23. Tartakower vs Petrov 0-1321930Hamburg OlympiadA45 Queen's Pawn Game
24. M Scheinberg vs Petrov  0-1271930Hamburg OlympiadA46 Queen's Pawn Game
25. Petrov vs S Takacs ½-½271930Hamburg OlympiadD78 Neo-Grunfeld, 6.O-O c6
 page 1 of 14; games 1-25 of 346  PGN Download
  REFINE SEARCH:   White wins (1-0) | Black wins (0-1) | Draws (1/2-1/2) | Petrov wins | Petrov loses  

Kibitzer's Corner
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 49 OF 52 ·  Later Kibitzing>
Nov-29-19  BUNA: <cameosis: he was latvian, not russian -- his correct name is vladimirs petrovs, not "vladimir petrov", the russified version. same with mihails tals ... but ignorance and cultural hegemony is still strong in the 21st century.> Vladimir Petrov was an ethnic russian who was born in Riga in 1908, when Latvia belonged to zarist Russia. Therefore in his birth certificate his name was definitely spelled Владимир Петров - i.e. Vladimir Petrov (english transliteration).

And Mikhail Tal was a russian-speaking soviet jew. Concerning his "latvianess": May I remind you that latvian nationalists together with the germans between 1941 an 1944 exterminated basically all latvian jews that they could get hold of and that Tal's family was fortunately among those evacuated at the beginning of the war by soviet authorities?

Nov-29-19  Absentee: Besides, "Vladimirs Petrovs" is about as Latvian as "Juans Sanchezis".
Nov-29-19  fabelhaft: <born in Riga in 1908, when Latvia belonged to zarist Russia. Therefore in his birth certificate his name was definitely spelled Владимир Петров - i.e. Vladimir Petrov>

Tal on the other hand was born in Riga when Latvia was still a sovereign state, so in his birth certificate his name was definitely spelled Mihails Tals.

Jan-04-20  cameosis: <spingo> you suppose wrong, but i commend you on your effort.

on another note, i don't see how your attempted quip would refute my statement.

Jan-04-20
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

<Gentlemen>

This is the first source note in the bio:

<Notes

(*) There are conflicting sources on the birth year of Vladimirs Petrovs. The Russian Wikipedia article, for example, gives *both* 1907 and 1908 as the birth year: Wikipedia article: https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9... In the kibbitzing section below, you can read a detailed account of which sources favor which birth year.>

Based on the preponderance of primary sources marshaled by <hemy>, it appears that 1907 is most likely the birth year of <Vladimirs Petrovs>. It could be 1908 though. His wife remembers that as his birth year in her memoir, but it could be a case like <Salo Flohr>, who by his own admission did not remember his own birth year, according to Genna Sosonko. At any rate, no birth certificate has yet been found, so it seems unlikely his real birth year will ever be proven beyond doubt.

I always use <Vladimirs Petrovs> when I type his name because that is the spelling he himself accepted. Though when writing to his wife he would call himself "Volodya" which was their pet name for him. In addition, <Petrovs> regarded himself to be Latvian, and proudly represented Latvia in international competitions. He took an active role in presiding over Olympic team selection, organizing Latvian chess events, and writing/editing for Latvian chess journals. Socially, on the other hand, according to his wife's memoir, they gravitated towards the robust Russian intellectual/artistic emigre society that flourished at that time in Riga. Their favorite writers, dancers, musicians and such were Russian, and they never missed a chance to see them when they performed in Riga.

Jan-04-20
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

On the use of <Vladimir Petrov> and <Mikhail Tal> as the spelling at cg.com, we have discussed that a few times over the years.

I thought there was some merit in using <Vladimirs Petrovs> and <Mihails Tals>, but in the end it was decided that we should use our current spellings simply because all the other chess databases use them.

At any rate, <Daniel> made the decision on that.

Jan-04-20
Premium Chessgames Member
  OhioChessFan: I am all for Petrovs...
Feb-18-20  chesshistoryinterest: I have found an item newly put onto Rusbase: "Team championship of Moscow - September 1942"

http://al20102007.narod.ru/nat_tour...

In it, they give Petrovs as one of the participants (perhaps they know this because they have a game for him, but the games link doesn't work).

But what particularly captures my attention is that they give the date of the event as September 1942. Yet in the Petrovs biography above, it has <On August 31, 1942, Petrovs was arrested>. Rusbase is occasionally wrong, or perhaps this "September 1942" is an end date of the event. Still, might be worth looking at.

Also, something else which looks a little bit odd is that the Petrovs biography says <Vladas Mikenas recalls that he expected to see Petrovs participate at the next major tournament in Kuibishev, but he never showed up.>. Yet the dates of the Kuibishev tournament were 27 July-19 August 1942

http://al20102007.narod.ru/nat_tour...

That gives Petrovs plenty of time to play in this event before his arrest (if it was 31 August 1942), so there must have been some other reason he wasn't there.

Feb-19-20  hemy: <chesshistoryinterest> <Team championship of Moscow - September 1942>

Rusbase mentioned as a source <"Vechernyaya Moskva", September 1942>.

I downloaded those newspapers and read all of them. No, nada.
<Rusbase is occasionally wrong> Rusbase want to compete with CNN.

Feb-20-20
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

<chesshistoryinterest> We may have to amend that arrest date for <Petrovs>. I don't think we can be sure of that, or even which camp he was sent to, or exactly when he died. The <Mikenas> material seems to be a bona fide reminiscence. It appears in <Fride>.

The Rusbase games link does work. Or "work" in this case. This syntax:

<ch_mot42.zip( games of 120)> means that the link has been published but the zip file is currently unpopulated. There are many of these in rusbase.

When he does find a game, he puts it in the .zip file and then changes the syntax to look like this:

<ch_mot42.zip(1 games of 120)>

When a number has been added in front of "games" then the link will go to the now populated .zip file and cough up the game.

##################

<hemy> Thank you so much for your diligence to look for that source. <Rusbase> does indeed have many errors. I have been working with it intensively the past two or three weeks on another project. I've also been working a lot recently in <chessbase> and I can tell you that <chessbase> also has many errors.

As you know, the gold standard as always is contemporaneous publications.

They have errors as well, but going by the Latvian periodicals those errors are almost always typographical mistakes in the pgn move lists.

I would say I have to do some work to reconstruct such pgns 10-20% of the time. This is a small price to pay though, in exchange for having accurate sites, dates, and player names.

Feb-20-20  chesshistoryinterest: <hemy>, <jessicafischerqueen>

A few preliminary remarks, then I'll get into it:

JFQ, thanks for explanation of Rusbase games link. When I tried the link, I got "Error 404". So now I know why I'm getting so many of these (perhaps he should have a better way of saying he's got no games, but as long as I know, that's fine).

<<Rusbase> does indeed have many errors. I have been working with it intensively the past two or three weeks on another project. I've also been working a lot recently in <chessbase> and I can tell you that <chessbase> also has many errors.> Yes, I'm also finding rather more than I would like. A bit like Di Felice, I suppose. I regard all three as indispensable to have as finding aids, but they sure need to be checked and confirmed as correct, if possible.

Fride on page 32 does say "In July 1989 the KGB admitted that Petrovs had been arrested August 31, 1942". Probably, we have to believe this date as being the most likely for the time being.

<Rusbase want to compete with CNN.> Ha, is that the Complete Non News? <I downloaded those newspapers and read all of them. No, nada.> Thanks from me, too, for this work, and I believe you. The September date did look a bit strange to me. Nevertheless, Rusbase must have found this somewhere, they wouldn't just publish this out of thin air. So I'm wondering if they've simply put the wrong month, and it's maybe actually August? If it was, that could mean a few things might click into place.

For example, this could be the event at which Petrovs made his fatal remarks. So far, all that is known is that it was after the Sverdlovsk tournament, but that is a while back (it finished 11 April 1942). And one would think that once informed, the authorities wouldn't have waited long to arrest him. Also:

In his comment of 10 January 2016, <roberts partner> Vladimir Petrov (kibitz #49) says <Voronkov had stated that the [three] informers were Muscovites who had played in several Soviet championships>.

Firstly, in regard to this and contrary to what a couple of posters suspect, I would say that Ragozin is probably not one of the three. Because like Botvinnik, he lived in Leningrad before the war and was probably evacuated from there in 1941. Thus in 1942, he would not have been regarded as a Muscovite, but as an evacuated Leningrader.

But now, look at the Rusbase item. Along with Petrovs in this event, we see Panov and Zubarev. Both of them were Muscovites who <had played in several Soviet championships> (Panov in the USSR Championships of 1934/5, 1937, 1939, 1940; Zubarev in those of 1920, 1923, 1925, 1933). So perhaps a few dots are connecting.

Other possibilities as to who were the informants may come from the participants of the Moscow tournament of 17 February-12 March 1942. Panov and Zubarev both also played in this. Other Moscow players who played in it were Yudovich, Dus-Chotimirsky and Alatortzev (the latter moved to Moscow from Leningrad about 1935). Yudovich played in the USSR Championships of 1931, 1933 1934/5, 1937, 1939; Dus-Chotimirsky those of 1923, 1924, 1925, 1927, 1933; Alatortzev those of 1931, 1933, 1934/5, 1937.

So it seems to me that the original source of the Rusbase item could be important to see; and that the August 1942 issues of the newspaper <Vechernyaya Moskva> newspaper should be checked to see if it can be found. This probably means more work for you, hemy, if you are willing - I would do it myself, but I cannot read Russian and therefore think it would be difficult for me to pick out such an item. Or else maybe Rusbase could be emailed asking for a precise reference(s) - day and page number.

Feb-20-20  hemy: <chesshistoryinterest>

<So it seems to me that the original source of the Rusbase item could be important to see; and that the August 1942 issues of the newspaper <Vechernyaya Moskva> newspaper should be checked to see if it can be found.>

Believe me or not, I already did it.
There is an information about start of this tournament and name of Petrov is mentioned. I will check the issues of "Vecherniaja Moskva" of September once more and also the issues on October (I already download) and post the results.

Feb-20-20  hemy: <chesshistoryinterest><jessicafischerqueen>

2 articles from "Vechernyaya Moskva" (Moscow Evening):

1. August 7, 1942, p. 4:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/5stqx46zy...

Summer chess-checker tournament.
In Moscow started team tournament of summer chess-checkers playgrounds and clubs. For the 1st place fighting teams of culture and relaxation parks "Gorky", "Stalin" and "Sokolniki", Central chess and checker club, "Ermitazh" garden, sport union "Spartak" and more. Together with them in the competition participating young chess and checker players from "Pioneers House".

In the tournament participating masters Zubarev, Panov, Petrov, Potapov.

In the 1st round team of Central chess-checkers club defeated park "Stalin" and "Sokolniki" park defeated Pioneer House team.

the 2nd day of the tournament - August 9th. The tournament will last 1.5 months.

2. October 2, 1942, p. 4:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/vnqle8nt4...

Chess Teams competition.
The competition between Moscow teams ended. Participated 6 teams, 8 chess players in each team. 1st place took the team of "Sokolniki" park - 30.5/40. 2nd was team of Central chess-checker club - 30/40. 3rd was "Ermitazh garden team - 19/40.

Feb-20-20  chesshistoryinterest: <hemy>

Fabulous, thanks very much. You have clearly found the information that Rusbase did. Strange that they couldn't be more accurate with the dating, but I'll take it!

I wonder what happened to the "Stalin" park team (or at least, that one is not mentioned by Rusbase as one of the 6 finishing the event - though how do they know?)? It would be ironic if that was the team that Petrovs was playing for.

My takes:

(1) Petrovs was arrested during this event. So it may well be here that he made his remarks. So perhaps the three masters who dobbed him in were Zubarev, Panov, and Potapov. Though Potapov does not take part in any USSR Championships and is very obscure to me.

(2) I have noticed that Zubarev and Panov are also in the Moscow Championship of 27 November 1941 - 5 January 1942. So these two are certainly in a lot of the same events as Petrovs. Perhaps they gained Petrovs' confidence.

(3) This event starts in the middle of the Kuibyshev (27 July - 19 August 1942) event. So Petrovs' arrest didn't keep him out of this Kuibyshev event. So there is some other, quite possibly perfectly innocent, reason why Petrovs did not play in this.

(4) So it would seem that Zubarev and Panov are the two most likely to be of those that informed on Petrovs. This does not constitute definite proof of course. So perhaps we'll never know for sure unless Voronkov changes his mind about informing the chess world who they were. Would it be possible that with 7 years having passed since his interview, he could be persuaded to do so?

At any rate, we have another Petrovs event, his last, that nobody knew about.

Feb-22-20  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen>

Re <roberts partner>, who was posting earlier on this page, I have worked out that he is Leonard Barden. His moniker is a reference to him being a consultation partner with Fischer in the game Fischer/Barden vs Penrose/Clarke 1960

Fischer / Barden vs Penrose / Clarke, 1960

He seems to still be active on this site, so maybe it could be an idea to contact him and see what his opinion is on this new information.

Feb-23-20  hemy: During long discussion about Petrov/Petrovs being Russian or Latvian I didn't express my opinion.
Some of the comments, posted in CG about this subject, were bothering me and finally I decided to share my knowledge about it.

I met many chess players that knew him personally: Vladas Mikenas, Isakas Vistaneckis, Simon Gordon (2-5 in Baltic Championship 1931), Alexander Koblents.

The idea that <his correct name is vladimirs petrovs, not "vladimir petrov", the russified version.> is dead wrong.

Petrov attended Russian school, used Russian language, attended Russian cultural events.

Vladimirs Petrovs is not a Latvian name, it is a Latvian way to spell the name Vladimir Petrov. In Lithuanian his name was translated to Vladimiras Petrovas.

In Lithuanian his wife's name would be Petrovene and his daughter's name Petrovaite.

<same with mihails tals ... but ignorance and cultural hegemony is still strong in the 21st century.> No one considered Mikhail Nekhemievich Tal as a Latvian. For Latvians he was a Jew, like Petrov was a Russian. They were not representing Latvian culture.

Feb-28-20  chesshistoryinterest: <hemy>

That's very interesting, informative and pretty convincing - it's clear you know what you are talking about.

Perhaps the Estonians could be regarded as fairly "neutral" in this respect - they are neither Russians; nor do they add "s" or "as" to their words. And they have it as "Petrov", eg see "Paul Keres - Photographs and Games". The Germans have it as "Petrow".

The "Petrovs" version seems to have been around for some time. In "Chess Tournament Crosstables 1921-1930" by Jeremy Gaige (published 1974): For the 3rd Latvian Chess Federation Congress, Section 1, Riga 1930, Gaige has him as "V. Petrov(s)" in the crosstable; and then for the playoff says "In the playoff, Petrovs beat Feigins: +4,=3,-1."

Then in "Chess Tournaments: A Checklist 1849-1950" (published 1985), Gaige has him as just "Petrovs".

In his "Chess Personalia" (published 1987), Gaige has "Petrovs, Vladimirs var. Petrov, Vladimir Mikhailovich".

In "Chess Results", Di Felice has him as "Petrovs".

Wikipedia has "Vladimirs Petrovs (Russian: Влади́мир Миха́йлович Петро́в, romanized: Vladimir Mikhailovich Petrov)".

Andris Fride in "Vladimirs Petrovs A Chessplayers Story From Greatness to the Gulags" has this to say in the introduction: "It will be noted here that his name is properly "Vladimirs Petrovs", even though it is often written "Petrov" in many English-language sources." But he doesn't give any genuine justification for claiming this. Only that it is "proper" from an anti-Soviet point of view: "The name "Petrov" is common in Russia and, therefore, to use that only made it easier to hide his disappearance and non-person status. We also like his proper name in pride for his nationality and in defiance of the bestial Soviet system". Unfortunately, there is no document in Fride with Petrov's signature on it, so we do not know how he signed himself. Fride is also inconsistent when he says "...Vladimirs Petrovs. Mikhail Tal came later of course." If he says "Vladimirs Petrovs", then he should be saying "Mikhails Tals".

So it seems to me that you are correct, hemy, that his name technically and accurately should be "Vladimir Petrov". "Petrovs" seems to be an inaccuracy that crept in some time ago and has taken hold.

I would presume by the same reasoning that you would regard "Simon Gordon" rather than "Simonas Gordonas" as correct; "Simon Disleris" rather than "Simonas Disleris" as correct; and "Gerz Gladstein" rather than "Gercas Gladsteinas" as correct.

Feb-28-20  hemy: <chesshistoryinterest>

Indeed <his name technically and accurately should be "Vladimir Petrov">

Latvian and Lithuanian languages are different, but having great similarity. My name in Lithuanian can be used as example of using foreign names in Lithuanian documents.

In 1995 the Embassy of Lithuania in Israel provided me document explaining the differences in my name (and my father's name Benianin as well) spelling in Israeli passport and Lithuanian birth certificate.

This is a scan of this document:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/u26fkh1lh...

Apr-14-20
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

<hemy>, <chesshistoryinterest>:

<"Petrovs" seems to be an inaccuracy that crept in some time ago and has taken hold.>

It is <Andris Fride> who stumped for "Vladimirs Petrovs" as the more accurate spelling.

<hemy's> take on this issue seems quite convincing to me- I will certainly be presenting his information in my documentary if I ever manage to finish it.

===

The Google translator for <Russian-English> has been improving by such orders of magnitude that I have perhaps been wasting time by re-translating <Galina Petrov's> autobiography about her husband. Every few months the translation makes more sense, so I have been transcribing and re-transcribing gradually over the last six months.

I will certainly include the stunning facts you gentlemen uncovered about <Petrov's> last known tournament.

To my knowledge, cg.com is now the only place where the information from <rusbase> has been included.

We should add that to the <Petrov> biography, of course. I am currently thinking about how best to do that as well.

Apologies for such slow work on my part.

Apr-28-20  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen>

<I will certainly include the stunning facts you gentlemen uncovered about <Petrov's> last known tournament> Yes, I did think this was pretty significant when I found it. The main credit must go to the Rusbase site, of course. I think that this site is, desplte a few relatively minor niggles, a hugely valuable and important resource.

*******

I have also found something else that will interest you. Re your post regarding the <Chess Grandmaster - Soldier Petrovs> interview (cited by Fride, pages 16-17) here:

Vladimir Petrov (kibitz #580)

I searched "Saha Maksla" through the rest of 1937 and did not find it. But Fride has given the wrong reference! I finally found it in "Jaunakas Zinas", 24 July 1937, page 14, here:

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Enjoy!! :)

Apr-28-20  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen>

Also, I found 2 Petrov games on Rusbase that you don't have:

(1) Mazel - Petrov, 21st Moscow Championship 1941/2 (0-1, 26)

(2) Bondarevsky - Petrov, Moscow 1942 (national tournament) (1/2-1/2, 19)

Neither of these tournaments have a Petrov game on chessgames.com so far.

Don't you just love Rusbase!!

Apr-28-20  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen>

I found another Petrov game you don't have: Petrov - Apsenieks, 2nd Reiner Cafe Tournament 1928/9 (the one with 5 players) (0-1, 55). "Centra Balss", 11 January 1929, page 7, here:

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Also, if you're into getting all games played by Latvian players, there are 4 additional games for the above event (2 by Apsenieks vs Bergs; and 2 by Apsenieks vs Elisons) on "Centra Balss" at

(1) 18 January 1929, page 7

(2) 25 January 1929, page 4

(3) 01 February 1929, page 5

(4) 08 February 1929, page 5

All annotated by Apsenieks.

Apr-28-20  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen>

There are errors/problems/missing info in the PGN's with some of the games you have for the Reiner Cafe tournaments.

There were three of these tournaments held in 1928/9 and they can be a bit confusing. I think I would maybe relabel them in "Event" (and elsewhere) as:

(1) "1st Reiner Cafe tournament (1928)" (this was the event held 9 - 24 November 1928 with 4 players).

(2) "2nd Reiner Cafe tournament (1928/9)" (this was the event held 20 December 1928 - 1 January 1929 with 5 players).

(3) "3rd Reiner Cafe tournament (1929)" (this was the event held 29 April - 5 May 1929 with 4 players).

The PGN errors/problems I found are:

(1) The Apsenieks - Feigin game played December 1928 (0-1, 26):

(a) You have event as "Reiner Cafe 4 players tournament". This refers to the 1st tournament. But this game was played in the 2nd tournament that had 5 players (Apsenieks did not play in the 1st tournament).

(b) You do not have day date or round. The date of "28 December 1928" given in the "Latvis" source is clearly wrong. "Jaunakas Zinas" already published this game on 24 December 1928 (page 10). From the tournament schedule, this clearly makes the game played in Round 3. And that implies a date of 22 December 1928.

(c) The "Latvis" source is on Page 5 of the 5 January 1929 issue.

(2) The Feigin - Apsenieks game played December 1928 (0-1, 61):

(a) As with the above game, <You have event as "Reiner Cafe 4 players tournament". This refers to the 1st tournament. But this game was played in the 2nd tournament that had 5 players (Apsenieks did not play in the 1st tournament).>

(b) You do not have day date or round. The date given in the "Latvis" source is 30 December 1928, and this clearly corresponds with Round 8.

(c) <The "Latvis" source is on Page 5 of the 5 January 1929 issue.>

(d) Black's 61st move is given as g2#. But it's not checkmate! White has 62.Bxg2. Only then is 62...Ng3 checkmate. The note in "Latvis" at the end of the game says "and mate next move".

(3) The Feigin - Bergs game played 1929 (1-0, 39):

(a) You do not have month/day date or round. The "Latvis" source says it is played 2 May 1929. Which from the schedule, clearly puts the game as played in Round 3.

(b) The "Latvis" source is on Page 4 of the 12 May 1929 issue.

(4) The game Petrov - Bergs played 29 April 1929 (1-0, 24):

The source is given as "'Latvis', May 12, 1929, p. 4". This is incorrect - this is the source of the Feigin - Bergs game above. The correct source for the Petrov - Bergs game is "'Rigasche Rundschau', 11 May 1929, page 17".

Apr-28-20  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen>

In regard to the new information on Petrov's last event, making (in my view) Panov and Zubarev as being the two most likely suspects as to who dobbed Petrov in, would it be an idea to see if Voronkov and Barden could be approached with this new information? If it's not done now, it may never happen;)

Apr-28-20  chesshistoryinterest: <hemy>

For the 2nd Reiner Cafe tournament (20 December 1928 - 1 January 1929), I am trying to establish whether Elisons lost his round 7 and 8 games over the board or by default.

The sources I have for trying to establish this are "Centra Balss", 4 January 1929, page 5

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

and "Jaunakas Zinas", 31 December 1928, page 10

http://data.lnb.lv/nba01/JaunakasZi...

But the writing is rather difficult to read, and Google translate isn't working very well. I was wondering if you might be able to translate them better. Or perhaps the "Today" paper might have something on it.

I think that Elisons probably played Round 7 (vs Feigins), but probably defaulted Round 8 (vs Bergs). (And probably withdrew from the tournament altogether after Round 7 - he had a bye in Round 9 and defaulted his Round 10 (last round) game to Petrov. And probably defaulted his adjourned Round 3 game against Berg, which was due to be resumed after Round 9.).

If this can be confirmed, I can complete the crosstable for this event.

Jump to page #    (enter # from 1 to 52)
search thread:   
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 49 OF 52 ·  Later Kibitzing>

NOTE: Create an account today to post replies and access other powerful features which are available only to registered users. Becoming a member is free, anonymous, and takes less than 1 minute! If you already have a username, then simply login login under your username now to join the discussion.

Please observe our posting guidelines:

  1. No obscene, racist, sexist, or profane language.
  2. No spamming, advertising, duplicate, or gibberish posts.
  3. No vitriolic or systematic personal attacks against other members.
  4. Nothing in violation of United States law.
  5. No cyberstalking or malicious posting of negative or private information (doxing/doxxing) of members.
  6. No trolling.
  7. The use of "sock puppet" accounts to circumvent disciplinary action taken by moderators, create a false impression of consensus or support, or stage conversations, is prohibited.
  8. Do not degrade Chessgames or any of it's staff/volunteers.

Please try to maintain a semblance of civility at all times.

Blow the Whistle

See something that violates our rules? Blow the whistle and inform a moderator.


NOTE: Please keep all discussion on-topic. This forum is for this specific player only. To discuss chess or this site in general, visit the Kibitzer's Café.

Messages posted by Chessgames members do not necessarily represent the views of Chessgames.com, its employees, or sponsors.
All moderator actions taken are ultimately at the sole discretion of the administration.

Spot an error? Please suggest your correction and help us eliminate database mistakes!
Home | About | Login | Logout | F.A.Q. | Profile | Preferences | Premium Membership | Kibitzer's Café | Biographer's Bistro | New Kibitzing | Chessforums | Tournament Index | Player Directory | Notable Games | World Chess Championships | Opening Explorer | Guess the Move | Game Collections | ChessBookie Game | Chessgames Challenge | Store | Privacy Notice | Contact Us

Copyright 2001-2025, Chessgames Services LLC