optimal play: <fredthebear: 25...Qb5?! is goofy in leu of resigning. Maybe the scoresheet is missing a move or two. White still eventually mates after 25...Qg5.>I did a search on TROVE and found the game:
<<<<SECOND ROUND : MILES v. WALLIS>
(English opening.)>
White, W. J. Miles ; Black, F. J. Wallis.>
1 PQB4 PKB4
2 PKB4 PK4 (a)
3 PQ3 (b) BKt5 ch
4 KtQB3 PxP
5 BxP KtKB3
6 PQR3 BxKt ch
7 PxB PQR3
8 KtKB3 KtQB3
9 PKKT3 QK2
10 BKt2 KtQ
11 Castles Castles
12 QQ2 RK
13 QRK PQ4
14 PxP QxRP
15 KtQ4 QQB4
16 KR KtB2
17 PK4 PxP
18 PxP (c) BQ2
19 BKt5 KtxB
20 QxKt RKB (d)
21 PK5 PKR3
22 QKt6 KtxP (e)
23 BK4 KtB3
24 RxKt RxR
25 PxR QKt4*
26 QR7 ch KB2
27 PxP Resigns>
*QKt4 Is this Q to QKt4 or Q to KKt4?
ie Qb5 or Qg5?
It's obvious that black played 25...QKKt4 (Qg5) and not 25...QQKt4 (Qb5)
White still mates in 9 after 25...Qg5 but it is nevertheless black's best move. It also accounts for white playing 26.Qh7+ which now makes sense.
I will submit a correction slip.
The newspaper report also included the following comments from the white player:
<<<NOTES BY MR. MILES.>
(a) Offering to play an open game.
(b) Which is declined.
(c) With a fine attack.
(d) If QxBP then PK5.
(e) If BK then QxPch and wins.>