Members · Prefs · Laboratory · Collections · Openings · Endgames · Sacrifices · History · Search Kibitzing · Kibitzer's Café · Chessforums · Tournament Index · Players · Kibitzing
Mikhail Botvinnik vs Nikolay Minev
Amsterdam Olympiad Final-A (1954), Amsterdam NED, rd 5, Sep-17
Semi-Slav Defense: Meran. Lundin Variation (D47)  ·  1-0



explore this opening
find similar games 1,188 more games of Botvinnik
PGN: download | view | print Help: general | java-troubleshooting

TIP: Some games have photographs. These are denoted in the game list with the icon.

PGN Viewer:  What is this?
For help with this chess viewer, please see the Olga Chess Viewer Quickstart Guide.


Kibitzer's Corner
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·  Later Kibitzing>
Nov-02-03  drukenknight: interesting analysis from rnd. There is a Seirewan game w/ Q/P vs Q I think. I know we had another one like this. I have no idea if the K went to the edge or not.

ALso you have to watch if you put your K/Q together sometimes that prevents the K from escaping a check.

Nov-02-03  drukenknight: rnd: Here is the other game with 2 queens and a pawn. Interestingly enuf there is an e pawn involved, which someone said leads to victory. At the end of the game, the stronger side is left with the pawn, but his K is not on a rank ahead of the pawn so it draws

Seirawan vs Xu Jun, 1988

Premium Chessgames Member
  Eggman: In Seirawan vs Xu Jun, 1988 the defending King is in front of the pawn - a hopeless draw. They only played this 191-move game out to get into the record books, I think.
Premium Chessgames Member
  Benzol: <rndapology> Thanks mate, I'm sorry if what I posted didn't make sense but at least you managed to get it. Hopefully it's clear now.
Premium Chessgames Member
  wwall: After 91.Kc5, then 91...Qc2+ 92.Qc4+ Ka3 93.g8=Q (93.Qxc2?? stalemate) 93...Qf2+ 94.Kd6 Qd4+ 95.Q8d5 (but not 95.Qxd4 stalmate) and White wins.
Sep-15-08  gambitfan: Again a very complicated winning endgame ♕ + ♙ // ♕
Sep-15-08  tsvanerp: If I was been black, I would go for a last trick: 91 .., Qc2+ 92 Qc4+ and now ... black reaches for his queen but "accidentally" touches the king, with a face expression "well, it doesn´t matter anyway, he moves 92 ..Ka3. White happy it is finally finished hastedly takes the queen 93 Qc2 stalemate .... ooops
Jan-19-09  WhiteRook48: Wow, I thought White couldn't stop all those checks! But he did!!
Premium Chessgames Member
  GrahamClayton: <rndapology>The idea is to block a check from the defender and give check at the same time or give check and attack the defender's queen(with your own queen defended) at the same time.

This game is a great example of the power of a "cross-check". Black resigned because all of his checks would be met by a cross-check, exchanging queens, eg:

91...♕c7+ 92.♕c6+
91...♕g1+ 92.♕d4+
91...♕f2+ 92.♕d4+
91...♕c2+ 92.♕c4+

Oct-29-12  vinidivici: what Botvinnik has done in this particular endgame is remarkable. The black king is remote from the hostile pawn and thats a big factor for Botvinnik to win. And also the white pawn is far advance on the board.

But a little bit notes that 77...Ka5 is an error the correct defense is 77...Ka3. When in this particular endgame the pawn is the rook or knight pawn, better place the king in the opposite corner, preventing counter check when the the stronger queen defense his own king.

But the defense complex and difficult. Even if you do 77... Ka3, your chance to lose still big, because its hard to defense meanwhile much easier to be the aggressive side.

Oct-30-12  SimonWebbsTiger: Looking back at the kibitzes from 2003, first raised by <aulero>, the computer tablebases have solved the Botvinnik-Minev endgame. An analysis of this is provided in "Dvoretsky's Endgame Manual". (pp.250-251; Russell Enterprises, 2nd Edition, 2008.)

Some general rules:
1) the stronger side should keep his king on the same file or rank as the opposing king, or on an adjacent rank or file (also true with more pawns on the board).

2) the stronger side should not place his king in front of the pawn.

3) the weaker side should place his king as far away in the diametrically opposite corner to the pawn's promotion square to avoid counter-checks.

But as Dvoretsky remarks, many of the tablebases reveal wins in 50+ moves with perfect play and that these types of endgames arise so rarely it isn't terribly practical to learn all the minutae of this Q+ (Knight) pawn versus Queen. Central and bishop pawns give the greatest winning chances compared to knight and rook pawns.

Oct-30-12  SimonWebbsTiger: ps. A recent practical example was

Marjanovic vs Beliavsky, 1987

Marjanovic annotated the game in Informator 44/109.

Oct-30-12  vinidivici: <Some general rules:
1) the stronger side should keep his king on the same file or rank as the opposing king, or on an adjacent rank or file (also true with more pawns on the board). 2) the stronger side should not place his king in front of the pawn.

3) the weaker side should place his king as far away in the diametrically opposite corner to the pawn's promotion square to avoid counter-checks.>

All's true.
Maybe theres an addition that
4) When the weaker side king's remote from the pawn and the pawn is rook/knight pawn then to win the stronger side king sooner or later has to try to get near the opponent king to create a position where all checks can be met with the counter check.

Just like the last position above.

91...Qf2+/Qc2+/Qc7+ are useless.

But if the pawn is the bishop pawn or the central pawn and the king is remote, then the draw chance is ZERO %, if one playing correctly.

Oct-31-12  SimonWebbsTiger: @<vinidivici>

yes, when white's knight pawn is at g7 and the queen d4 with the black king in the vicinity of the a1 corner, Averbakh in his famous endgame series gives several positions demonstrating the winning procedure with the white king close by, instead of at eg. f6

BTW, absolutely correct too that Minev's Ka5 was the wrong way. Which immediately shows Botvinnik gave a useless check which should have forced the king to go where it has to go anyway! As noted, Dvoretsky points out the correct winning method in his manual, as found by the silicon.

If interested, check out the Endgame Corner by Karsten Mueller on The April 2003 column (in the archive section) has a bit on Q+RP v. Q, with practical examples.

Oct-31-12  vinidivici: <Simon>
Yes, i have read all Dvo's Endgame Manual contents.
Good book.

Q vs Q + pawn doesnt so often appear in the practical matches, you need to practice sometimes, but maybe knowing the basic principles for queen endgames is enough. I rarely found in my own games, and the winning line could be up to more than 60 moves.

Premium Chessgames Member
  perfidious: < vinidivici: Yes, i have read all Dvo's Endgame Manual contents. Good book....>

As is the whole series.

<....Q vs Q + pawn doesnt so often appear in the practical matches....>

Never had either side of Q+P vs Q in thirty years of play, in a serious game or even rapid play.

Oct-31-12  vinidivici: <As is the whole series. > Is it have a series? Perhaps you meant by that is the different editions or revision. I learnt from Manual Endgame about 5 years ago. I kind of delve deeper my analytical part now. So im reading a different expert book now.

<Never had either side of Q+P vs Q in thirty years> I mean, in the blitz or rapid or standard (15 minutes game), in the online games, sometimes it appears, say 1 from 50 games. But Not exactly Q P v Q but also Q +pawns v Q+ pawns. But in the competitive plays it really really rare.

<thirty years of play> Wow, 30 years, thats a long time. I might be would never reach your kind of experiences. Won't reveal my name though. I even dont have a quarter of your experiences.

Premium Chessgames Member
  perfidious: Dvoretsky published five books and they're all worth owning-if you can find them.
Nov-01-12  vinidivici: <perf>

Dont need to tell me though.

I said <Yes, i have read all Dvo's ENDGAME MANUAL contents. Good book.>

You <as is the whole series>

I dont think Endgame Manual has the series.

I tell you that Endgame Manual has no series just revisions.

By the way, dont worry about getting his books.
And you are WRONG about 5 books. Its MORE than that. far more.

Premium Chessgames Member
  perfidious: Maybe I'm not wrong-he wrote a five-volume series dealing with various aspects of the game-not just endings.
Nov-01-12  vinidivici: But still you are wrong about 5 books.
Premium Chessgames Member
  perfidious: <vini> Had hopes I was wrong about you, but they were not to be. Your misbehaviour has reasserted itself.
Mar-13-14  Marmot PFL: <According to Fine's Basic Chess Endings (published, I believe, before the Minev game but after the Ravinsky game) this should be a draw. Hmmm ... >

Both sides made mistakes according to the computer analysis, but Fine was probably right. I believe his conclusion was based on an analysis by Keres.

This game was adjourned twice but even the best human analysis can only do so much and even if the game follows those lines they have to be remembered at the board. The stronger player had an advantage and won, as usually happens.

Jun-18-18  Omnipotent00001: After the exchange of rooks it's a draw.
Premium Chessgames Member
  g15713: E. 1.0
White to move at 41

click for larger view

White played 41. Kf2 but after 41. Rxa7 White is winning according to FinalGen

E. 1.1
Black to move at 41

click for larger view

A few sample lines:

Line 1: 41...Rc1+ 42. Kf2 Rc2+ 43. Kf3 Rxb2

E. 1.2

click for larger view

Syzygy says White is winning

Line 2: 41... e5 42. g4 e4 43. g5 e3 44. g6 Rc1+ 45. Kg2 e2 46. Rd7+ Ke5 47. Re7+ Kf6 48. Rxe2 Kxg6

E. 1.3

click for larger view

Syzygy says White is winning

Line 3: 41...Ke3 42. h4 Rh8 43. Ra3+ Ke2 44. Ra5 Rxh4 45. Re5+ Kd3 46. Rxe3

E. 1.4

click for larger view

Syzygy says Black is losing

Going back to diagram E. 1.0

Game continued:

41.Kf2 a5 42.g4 Rc2+ 43.Kg3 Rxb2 44.g5 a4 45.g6 Rb1 46.Kh4 Rg1 47.Kh5 Kc4 48.Rf4+ Kb5 49.Rf3 Kb4 50.Rf4+ Kb5 51.Rf3 Kb4 52.Rg3 Rxg3 53.hxg3 a3 54.g7 a2 55.g8=Q a1=Q

F. 1.0
White to move at 56

click for larger view

Syzygy says it is a tablebase draw

56.Qg4+ Ka5 57.Qxe6 Qh8+ 58.Kg6 Qc3 59.g4 Qd2 60.g5

F. 1.1
Black to move at 60

click for larger view

Syzygy says it is a tablebase draw with 60...Ka4 or Kb4 or Qc3 or Qd8 or Qh2 '

60...Qd4? <Normally centralizing one's queen is a good idea but not here, Ka4 or Kb4! heading towards southwest corner>

61.Qf5+? <Kh7! "the stronger side should not place his king in front of the pawn.">

61...Ka4 62.Kh5 Qh8+ 63.Kg4

63...Qh1? <Ka3 or Kb3 or Qd8! again the Black king should head towards southwest corner>

64.Qf4+ Ka5 65.Qe5+ Ka4 66.g6 Qd1+ 67.Kg5 Qd8+ 68.Kf5 Qc8+ 69.Kf4 Qc1+ 70.Qe3 Qc7+ 71.Qe5 Qc1+ 72.Kf5 Qc8+ 73.Kg5 Qd8+ 74.Qf6 Qd5+ 75.Qf5 Qd8+ 76.Kh5 Qe8

F. 1.2
White to move at 77

click for larger view

Syzygy says White is winning

77.Qf4+? <Kg4!>

A sample line is <77. Kg4! Qe2+ 78. Kf4 Qd2+ 79. Ke5 Qb2+ 80. Kd6 Qb8+ 81. Ke7 Qb4+ 82. Kf7 Qb7+ 83. Kf6 Qb6+ 84. Qe6> Dvoretsky

77...Ka5? <Going the wrong way - Ka3! is the correct move to draw>

78.Qd2+ Ka4 79.Qd4+ Ka5 80.Kg5 Qe7+ 81.Kf5 Qf8+ 82.Ke4 Qh6 83.Qe5+ Ka4 84.g7 Qh1+ 85.Kd4 Qd1+ 86.Kc5 Qc1+ 87.Kd6 Qd2+ 88.Ke6 Qa2+ 89.Qd5 Qe2+ 90.Kd6 Qh2+ 91.Kc5 1-0

search thread:   
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·  Later Kibitzing>

NOTE: Create an account today to post replies and access other powerful features which are available only to registered users. Becoming a member is free, anonymous, and takes less than 1 minute! If you already have a username, then simply login login under your username now to join the discussion.

Please observe our posting guidelines:

  1. No obscene, racist, sexist, or profane language.
  2. No spamming, advertising, duplicate, or gibberish posts.
  3. No vitriolic or systematic personal attacks against other members.
  4. Nothing in violation of United States law.
  5. No cyberstalking or malicious posting of negative or private information (doxing/doxxing) of members.
  6. No trolling.
  7. The use of "sock puppet" accounts to circumvent disciplinary action taken by moderators, create a false impression of consensus or support, or stage conversations, is prohibited.
  8. Do not degrade Chessgames or any of it's staff/volunteers.

Please try to maintain a semblance of civility at all times.

Blow the Whistle

See something that violates our rules? Blow the whistle and inform a moderator.

NOTE: Please keep all discussion on-topic. This forum is for this specific game only. To discuss chess or this site in general, visit the Kibitzer's Café.

Messages posted by Chessgames members do not necessarily represent the views of, its employees, or sponsors.
All moderator actions taken are ultimately at the sole discretion of the administration.

This game is type: CLASSICAL. Please report incorrect or missing information by submitting a correction slip to help us improve the quality of our content.

<This page contains Editor Notes. Click here to read them.>

Featured in the Following Game Collections[what is this?]
Botvinnik's Best Games 1947-1970
by uglybird
Q+1p vs. Q
from Endgame technique by zorro
Queen vs Queen
from Endgames World champions - part two by Alenrama
Queen versus Queen and Pawn
from armarosis' favorite endgames by armarosis
6) Queen Endings
from The Greatest Ever Chess Endgames by K9Empress
Q+P wins vs Q
from Basic endings by avidfan
K+Q+P vs K+Q
from Endgames I Need To Study by JDPK37
Checks ended!
from The Best Chess Games (part 1) by Dr Esenville
Hit the cross check, dont you come back no more no more...
from DeepBlade's favorite games by DeepBlade
Q+P vs P Ending
from 1954 Chess Olympiad by chessmoron
botvinnik best games
by brager
Black's 60th, White's 61st, B's 63rd, W's 77th, B's 77th
from Annotated by Tablebase by Judah
Botvinnik's best games
Mikhail Botvinnik's Best Games
by KingG
by Morphischer
R --> Q
from 23_Rook endings with pawn races on opposite wing by whiteshark
48a_ QUEEN endgames - all the single Ladies
by whiteshark
Game #12
from The most beautiful games in chess by keywiz84
from 64idi0t's_misc by 64idi0t
from Mammoth Book of Chess by relue
plus 39 more collections (not shown)

Home | About | Login | Logout | F.A.Q. | Profile | Preferences | Premium Membership | Kibitzer's Café | Biographer's Bistro | New Kibitzing | Chessforums | Tournament Index | Player Directory | Notable Games | World Chess Championships | Opening Explorer | Guess the Move | Game Collections | ChessBookie Game | Chessgames Challenge | Store | Privacy Notice | Contact Us

Copyright 2001-2023, Chessgames Services LLC