Dec-23-24 J Lord vs Sothers, 1874 
| |
| CarlHaffner: The notation of this game shows an impossible move for White on move 46. Does anyone know where this game comes from? |
|
|
|
Sep-19-24 W Schmidt vs E Fuckner, 1909
| |
| CarlHaffner: This game is identical to the following game: W Schmidt vs E Fuckner, 1909 . |
|
|
|
Sep-18-24 N Whitaker vs F Walker, 1916
| |
| CarlHaffner: The stated move 54. ... Qc7 is an impossible move. But I don't understand the source given in the PGN file (Washington Post, 1916.06.04): "49 P-Kt4 Q-KKt
50 Kt-Kt6 PxKt
ch. PxRPch
51 PxR Q-KB
52 R-Kt2 PxP
53 P-Q4 Q-B2
54 R-KR3 "
Does this make sense to anyone? |
|
|
|
Sep-18-24 S Levitsky vs S Izbinsky, 1911
| |
| CarlHaffner: Diese Schachpartie ist identisch mit der folgenden Partie: S Levitsky vs S Izbinsky, 1911 . |
|
|
|
Sep-18-24 K Meissner vs M Gargulak, 1913
| |
| CarlHaffner: This game is identical to the following game: K Meissner vs M Gargulak, 1913 |
|
|
|
Sep-18-24 Reti vs Spielmann, 1913
| |
| CarlHaffner: This game is identical to the following game: Reti vs Spielmann, 1913 |
|
|
|
Sep-17-24 K Treybal vs M Gargulak, 1907
| |
| CarlHaffner: This chess game seems to be identical to the following game: K Treybal vs M Gargulak, 1907 |
|
|
|
Sep-17-24 G MacDonnell vs de Vere, 1866
| |
| CarlHaffner: This chess game is identical to the game G MacDonnell vs De Vere, 1867 |
|
|
|
Sep-14-24 St. Petersburg vs City of Dorpat, 1838
| |
| CarlHaffner: See the duplicate: St. Petersburg vs City of Tartu, 1838 |
|
|
|
Sep-09-24 V Svensons vs K Svenson, 1892
| |
| CarlHaffner: Deutsche Schachzeitung 1895, p. 166: „Die Partie wurde als Remis abgebrochen, wie uns scheint mit Unrecht, da 37. Tf3 voraussichtlich den Gewinn erzwungen hätte.“ (“The game was abandoned as a draw, wrongly it seems to us, since 37. Rf3 would probably have forced a ... |
|
|
|
| indicates a reply to the comment. |
|
Kibitzing
