Sneaky: OK, let's walk through this composition with help of my handy PC chess engine. White to play and Draw.
 click for larger view<SPOILER ALERT> If you want to solve this on your own, stop reading now. . . . A pretty realistic position for a composition. Black has more material and lots of threats, so White has to act immediately to avoid doom. You might be tempted to give up the knight and try to find perpetual check with Qb3+, or Qc1+, but you'll find that Black can wriggle out of those naive attempts. Some quiet queen moves like 1.Qf1? simply fail to the skewer 1...Ra1. The key move is the one move that seems impossible: to release the protection that important g-pawn with 1.Nf4!!
 click for larger viewNow Black's hand is forced due to twin threats of Qd3# and Ne5#. (That's why the pin 1...Ra1 is no defense: 2.Ne5#!) So Black makes the one move that looks like it should work, 1...Qxg3+.  click for larger viewWhite can now answer a check with a check: 2.Ng2+
2...Qxg2+? is no good because after 3.Bxg2 White simply has too much material. So Black must play 2...Ke4. This opens up the door to a cute stalemate trick, 3.Qxa4!!  click for larger viewIf 3...bxa4 it's instantly a stalemate. The move 3...Qd6 looks pretty sensible, protecting both bishops, but I believe that 4.Ne1+ should be good to allow White to hold that position. (The analysis of that is pretty hairy and not the highlight of the problem, so let's gloss over that for now.) So Black, faced with a queen-sac trick, shows that he has a queen-sac trick of his own, 3...Qh2+!!  click for larger viewWhat is White to do? Certainly not 4.Kxh2? bxa4 where Black is clearly winning. Also certainly not 4.Kf1?? which leads to mate after ...bxa4+. So there is only one move, 4.Kf2. Black's fun isn't over yet! Let's offer the queen again with 4...Qg1+!!  click for larger viewOnce again, taking the queen 5.Kxg1? is taboo because after ...bxa4 Black is winning. And of course 5.Ke2?? is suicidal. So 5.Kg3 it must be. And then Black offers the queen yet again, 5...Qf2+!!  click for larger view6.Kh2 is forced, and then one last offer 6...Qg3+!!
 click for larger viewWhite is now forced to play 7.Kg1 and we have repeated position one time. Play ring-around-the-rosey two more times and we have achieved the draw! I'm not going to say this is the greatest composition ever, but seeing the queen go g3+ h2+ g1+ f2+ three times is unforgettable. Seeing Black's queen-sac as the only reasonable reply to White's queen-sac is simply sublime. Justly, Kasparian earned first place for this composition. |