< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 3 OF 3 ·
Later Kibitzing> |
Jun-27-13 | | Karpova: <Rotlewi ist kurz nach seinem großartigen Erfolg in Karlsbad an einem schweren Nervenleiden erkrankt, welches seinen Eintritt in ein Sanatorium notwendig machte.> Dr. Johannes Esser was his medical advisor. Source: Page 113 of the 1912 'Wiener Schachzeitung' |
|
Aug-28-13 | | Karpova: From Georg Rotlewi <A.J.G. Soltis continues: "And he would have tied for First Place ... had he won his final game. (!!)> This is wrong as Rotlewi finished 1 point behind Rubinstein and Schlechter and 2 points behind the winner Teichmann, after losing to Leonhardt (shared 8th place) in the last round: Karlsbad (1911) |
|
Aug-28-13 | | Karpova: More on the 2nd Match between Salwe and Rotlewi from page 40 of the 1911 'Wiener Schachzeitung': The 10-games match took place in Lodz
............ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Rotlewi... = = 1 = = = 1 = 1 0 .. 6.0
Salwe..... = = 0 = = = 0 = 0 1 .. 4.0
The date is not given but as this was page 40 (i. e. the January issue), the match may have taken place at the end of 1910 also. On the same page, it is reported that the Lodz Chess Club had planned an interesting tournament for November 1910 which was postponed and never took place. The players were to be Rotlewi, Alekhine, Salwe, Spielmann and Teichmann. In December 1910, an enlarged and even more beautiful project appeared but it was postponed due to San Sebastian 1911 and San Remo 1911 (both tournaments took place in spring) but no further details are offered. |
|
Aug-29-13 | | Karpova: 4-masters double-round robin tournament in Munich, 1911 (started at the beginning of May and ended on May 18). 1. Alapin 4.5
2. Rotlewi 4.0
3. Spielmann 2.0
4. Fahrni 1.5
Rotlewi scored +2 =4 -0 (winning games against Fahrni and Spielmann). Source: Pages 237-238 of the 1911 'Wiener Schachzeitung' |
|
Aug-29-13 | | Karpova: In Amsterdam, the Netherlands, December 1911, Rotlewi contested a match with Dr. Johannes Esser but the match was interrupted after 5 games (+0 =3 -2) as Rotlewi moved away from his domicile (<Amsterdam. Rotlevi spielte Ende Dezember mit Dr. Esser einen Wettkampf, der nicht beendet werden konnte, da Rotlevi sein Domizil wechselte.>). The result was kept secret at first, in deference to Rotlewi's participation at San Sebastian (1912). But he didn't participate and it was revealed that he started to suffer from a severe neuropathy shortly after Karlsbad (1911). He had to be hospitalized in a sanatorium (see my post Georg Rotlewi ) and as his medical advisor, Dr. Johannes Esser wanted to avoid everything that could have had a negative impact on Rotlewi's frame of mind (<Unter diesen Umständen sah sich Dr. Esser als Rotlewis ärztlicher Berater verpflichtet, alles zu vermeiden, was den Gemütszustand seines Patienten hätte ungünstig beeinflussen können.>). Source: Page 113 of the 1912 'Wiener Schachzeitung'
This leads to the following conjecture: Karlsbad (1911) ended on September 24 and three months later, Rotlewi stayed in Amsterdam but then <moved away> interrupting a match which was not going well for him. Possibly, Rotlewi suffered some kind of breakdown afer his greatest success and, as a result, may have become a patient of Dr. Esser in Amsterdam. At the end of the year, his condition became so critical that he had to be hospitalized in a sanatorium (i. e. the move from his domicile). This seems to have ended his chess career and the match was his (so far) last known serious contest. Still, his condition improved a bit as they finally decided to publish the result in the April-May issue of the 1912 'Wiener Schachzeitung'. |
|
Aug-29-13
 | | Tabanus: <Karpova> The New York Sun, 22 October 1911 has a picture of Rotlewi sitting at the chess board. According to the newspaper it was forwarded by his uncle B. Laski in New York: "In view of the short arrival of the Russian youth, G. A. Rotlewi, who, by the way, is engaged in a series of five games with Marshall at the Cafe Kerhau[?], Berlin, it will not be out of place to give his latest photo, as kindly forwarded by his uncle, B. Laski, of this city." Apparently he was expected to play in New York in "the international
tourney, scheduled to begin in the last week of February" (1912). |
|
Aug-30-13 | | Karpova: <Tabanus>
Thanks for the hint!
The Sun (New York N.Y.]), Sunday, 1911.10.22, 3rd section, page 9: http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/l... Dr. Lasker also mentioned Rotlewi's intention to go to the USA. As he was still in Berlin at the end of October and in Amsterdam at the end of December, it is probably rather unlikely that he made it, as his neuropathy must also have developed / shown symptoms around that time. Perhaps, some information on the 5-games contest between Rotlewi and Marshall was preserved somewhere. |
|
Aug-30-13
 | | Tabanus: <Karpova> I just found something else which will interest you, if you have not seen it. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 12 October 1911:
"The ranks of metropolitan chess players are to receive an important addition in the person of G. A. Rotlewi of Lodz, Russia, who distinguished himself by carrying off the fourth prize at Carlsbad, where he made his debut in an international
tournament. The young Russian will come to this country shortly, and
would have been here sooner but for an engagement to play chess in Berlin. It appears that it will not be the first time that Rotlewi has visited America. He has an uncle, who is B. Laski of 235 Mercer street, Manhattan. According to the latter, Rotlewi lived here for a while at the age of 14 years. He is now 21. Mr. Laski is under the impression that his nephew proposes to make America his home." |
|
Aug-30-13
 | | Tabanus: Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 26 October 1911 (again by Hermann Helms): "It is now reported, on the authority of Wochenschach of Berlin, that the series of five games between F. J. Marshall and G. A. Rotlewi will not take place. On October 1, Marshall played against 25 opponents of the Augustea in Leipsic, making a score of 20 wins, 4 losses and 1 draw." Perhaps this match was not played!? Also I'm not sure if the international event in New York Feb. 1912 ever took place. |
|
Aug-30-13 | | Karpova: <Tabanus>
Regarding New York 1912, the 1911 'Wiener Schachzeitung' reports on pages 174-175 that an International Tournament in New York of the highest order was planned for January 8 (double-round robin, 9 Europeans, 3 Americans) and refer to the 'Brookly Daily Eagle' of May 11, 1911. Hartwig Cassel and Hermann Helms were in charge of it and H. F. Ridder also involved. Then, on pages 260-261 of the 1912 'Wiener Schachzeitung', the New - York Havana International Tournament, which had been reported in the press during the last 2 years and never taken too seriously was announced to not take place. Cassel, Helms and Ridder had retreated and less well-known people had assumed control. The last try was to organize it to begin on November 30, 1912. This was now expanded to a WC tournament (the first 4 players would have played a quadruple-round robin to determine the new WC) including Dr. Lasker, Spielmann, Tarrasch, Teichmann, Duras, Maroczy, Schlechter, Dr. Vidmar, Dr. Bernstein, Niemzowitsch, Rubinstein, Burn, Janowski, Capablanca and Marshall (double-round robin, 1st leg in New York, 2nd in Havana). So no chance for Rotlewi. Apparently, Dr. Lasker (in the 'Pester Lloyd') was not satisfied and wouldn't have played, had Capablanca been invited. Furthermor, he considered the participation of Maroczy, Rubinstein, Tarrasch and Dr. Vidmar doubtful (it's not clear why. Maybe he thought they wouldn't have travelled so far?). But all of this ended as soon as the news appeared that the tournament wouldn't take place anyway. |
|
Aug-30-13
 | | Tabanus: <Karpova> Great, thanks. I see you deleted the Lasker match from the bio, I think rightly so. I found him in the Hamburg passenger lists:
Name: George Rotlewi
Departure Date: 2 Apr 1904
Estimated Birth Year: abt 1889
Age: 15. Gender: männlich (Male)
Marital Status: ledig (Single)
Residence: Lodz
Ethnicity/Nationality: Russland (Russian)
Ship Name: Pretoria
Emigration: nein
Ship Flag: Deutschland
Port of Departure: Hamburg
Port of Arrival: Boulogne; Plymouth; New York |
|
Aug-30-13 | | Karpova: <Tabanus>
Thanks for the additional info - I added it to the bio. Helms' column from October 12, 1911: http://fultonhistory.com/Newspapers... |
|
Nov-25-13 | | Karpova: The recently added game Juenger vs Rotlewi, 1911 gives rise to some interesting speculations. Rotlewi's opponent is most likely Dr. Ernst Georg Jünger, the father of Ernst Jünger. The game appears to be an offhand game. Rehburg is a very small town (pop. 4,000) and today not independent (largest borough of Rehburg-Loccum; pop. 10,000). Rehburg-Loccum, Lower Saxony, is located near Hanover. So it is rather far away from all of Rotlewi's playing locations (1911: Munich, Cologne and Carlsbad) and it seems too small for a chess event like a Simul. According to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rehbur... there was a health resort. If it was still in use in 1911, I could imagine that Rotlewi spend some time in the health resort and on this occasion played the (or several) friendly game(s) against Dr. Jünger. |
|
Feb-14-14 | | Karpova: According to Eduard Miksch, Rotlewi was not allowed to participate in Karlsbad (1911), because he had already played in the Cologne Main tournament A.* However, Janowski didn't come,** and so Rotlewi was admitted to play. (<Von Rechts wegen hätte er gar nicht zugelassen werden sollen, weil er in Köln mitspielte. Da aber Janowski nicht kam, durfte er einspringen.>) Source: Page 373 of the November-December 1911 'Wiener Schachzeitung' (originally in 'Bohemia' of October 1 and 8, 1911) * For another such case see Sergey Nikolaevich Von Freymann ** Janowski is included in the preliminary list of participants on page 200 of the June 1911 'Wiener Schachzeitung' |
|
Mar-02-14 | | Karpova: Dr. Emanuel Lasker, Berlin, September 14, 1911:
<Zu ihnen hat sich ein ganz Junger gesellt, der den Mut hat, seinem eigenen Urteile zu folgen. Und dazu des Vorrechts der Jugend sich bedient, die Dinge in rosigem Lichte zu sehen. Daher streitet er ohne Bedenken und in naivem Glauben an seinen Stern so tapfer wie ein schwäbischer Kreuzritter, wenn schon die Feinde ihn ringsum bedrängen. Er bringt einen frischen Zug in die Arena des Schachwettstreits, und solche neuen Impulse sind wohltätig, weil das Schach, wo es stagniert, die Neigung hat, an des "Gedankens Blässe" zu kranken.> (A very young man has joined them [Teichmann, Schlechter and Rubinstein, leading at Karlsbad (1911)], who has the courage to follow his own opinion. And therefore he makes use of the privilege of the youth, to view the things in rosy light. So he fights without concerns and in naive belief in his star, as brave as a Swabian crusader, when he is already surrounded by his enemies. He brings a fresh breeze into the arena of chess contest, and such new impulses are beneficial, because chess, where it stagnates, is disposed to suffer from the "pale cast of thought".) Source: 'Pester Lloyd', 1911.09.17, page 10 |
|
May-13-14 | | Karpova: Very interesting C.N. 8658, wherein pages 44-45 of 'Ernst Jünger' by Julien Hervier (Paris, 2014) are cited. Rotlewi is mentioned: <Ernst Jünger, qui l’accompagne dans de longues promenades à travers la lande, est frappé par sa personnalité douloureuse.> and, when asked why he was so sorrowful, quoted Schiller's 'Wallensteins Tod': <Qu’est-ce qu’une vie que l’amour n’éclaire pas?> Link: http://www.chesshistory.com/winter/... I once found this game of Rotlewi against a member of the Jünger family, played in Rehburg: Juenger vs Rotlewi, 1911 |
|
Jun-06-14 | | whiteshark: According to Calle Erlandsson (cited in C.N. 1392; Vol. 6/1987) Rotlewi's first name was <Gedali Abram>, not Georg or Gersz. Bachmann's yearbooks initially wrote his surname as <Rothlewy>. Source: Schach-Report/Dt.Schachblätter 2/1996 p. 71 |
|
Aug-18-14
 | | Penguincw: R.I.P. Georg Rotlewi, probably whose most famous game was in a losing effort: Rotlewi vs Rubinstein, 1907. |
|
Aug-18-14 | | Howard: That's probably quite correct. There are a few other players, too, whose best-known game was one that they LOST. Treybal's losses to Alekhine and to Capablanca, would be another such example. Those two games were undoubtedly two of his most "famous" games---but for the wrong reason. |
|
Aug-18-14
 | | Penguincw: I'll add another one: Donald Byrne (I think you get the point). |
|
Sep-29-14 | | Karpova: Rotlewi played a 13-board Simul in the <Bremer Schachgesellschaft von 1877> (Bremen, Germany) on 22 April 1911. He scored +11 -0 =2 (Schwarte and Spieß drew). Source: http://www.bremersg.de/%C3%BCber-un... |
|
Aug-27-16
 | | MissScarlett: Is there an obituary notice which gives a date of death, or, at least, clarifies whether Rotlewi was aged 30 or 31? |
|
Apr-04-19 | | Caissanist: Among players whose best-known game is one they lost, there's one quite familiar name: Deep Fritz vs Kramnik, 2006 . |
|
May-05-20 | | myllyniemi14: The game, from the sixth round of 1907 Lodz double-round robin tournament, played between Rotlewi (white) and Georg Salwe (black): 1. d4 d5 2. c4 e6 3. ♘c3 ♘f6 4. ♗g5 ♗e7 5. ♘f3 0-0 6. e3 ♘e4 7. ♗xe7 ♕xe7 8. ♕b3 c6 9. ♗d3 f5 10. 0-0 ♘d7 11. ♖ad1 ♔h8 12. ♘d2 ♘df6 13. f3 ♘xd2 14. ♖xd2 e5 15. cxd5 exd4 16. exd4 ♕e3+ 17. ♖ff2 ♕xd4 18. ♗xf5 ♕e5 19. ♗e4 cxd5 20. ♘xd5 ♗e6 21. ♕c3 ♕xc3 22. ♘xc3 ♖f7 23. ♖d6 ♖e8 24.♖e2 ♗c4 25. ♗d5 ♖xe2 26. ♘xe2 ♗xd5 27. ♖d8+ ♘g8 28. ♖xd5 g6 29. ♘c3 ♔g7 30. ♔f2 ♘f6 31. ♖d4 ♖c7 32. ♔e3 ♔f7 33. ♖f4 ♔e7 34. ♖xf6 ♖xc3+ 35. bxc3 ♔xf6 36. ♔e4 ♔e6 37. f4 h5 38. h3 h4 39. ♔f3 ♔f5 40. g4+ hxg3 e.p 41. ♔xg3 b5 42. ♔f3 a6 43. h4 a5 44. a3 a4 45. ♔g3 and black resigned Source: <Neue Lodzer Zeitung, 21-04-1907, page 135> |
|
Oct-05-20
 | | FSR: I hadn't realized how strong Rotlewi was. His performance at Karlsbad 1911 was outstanding. Chessmetrics ranks him as No. 12 in the world in January and February 1912, ahead of Alekhine, Maroczy, Tartakower, and Janowski. http://chessmetrics.com/cm/CM2/Play... Had he not become ill, I have no doubt that he would have become one of the very best players in the world. Tragically, his entire chess career lasted just six years. Much like Kieseritzky, he is remembered today mainly for losing one immortal game. |
|
 |
 |
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 3 OF 3 ·
Later Kibitzing> |
|
|
|