May-17-13 Norway Chess Tournament (2013) 
| |
|
keypusher: <True to some degree, his ratings were earned by beating rabbits via cheap endgame tricks, but what can he do but to eat what is served.> As frogbert demonstrated at length, Carlsen's rating owes less to beating <rabbits> (if by rabbit we mean GMs rated 2700-2750, ...
|
|
| | May-17-13 Carlsen vs Wang Hao, 2013 
| |
|
keypusher: Looks hopeless to me. Luckily I'm incompetent.
|
|
| | May-17-13 Svidler vs Karjakin, 2013 
| |
|
keypusher: <chessdgc2: caissafan1963: Have you looked at ...Bxb5? After 1...c6 then 2.a5 and if 2...Bxa5 then 3. Bxd7 Qxd7 4. Rxa5 Seems like White is trying to trick Black :)> 3.Bxd7 is unplayable.
Strongest Force's 14....c6 15.a5 Bxd4 is the official site's engine's choice but it ...
|
|
| | May-16-13 Anand-Carlsen World Championship (2013) 
| |
|
keypusher: <nok: <rhickma4> was witty and an answer wasn't quite necessary, we all know that.> One man's witty is another man's moronic.
|
|
| | May-16-13 Kenneth Rogoff 
| |
|
keypusher: <OneArmedScissor: <kb2ct is a loon. He claims to trade currency or something, but he doesn't even know what GDP is. His nonsense is not attributable to anyone but himself.> Why do you need to know what GDP is in order to trade currency?> I've never known anyone who did
|
|
| | May-16-13 Viswanathan Anand 
| |
|
keypusher: <We need a REAL champion like Muhammad Ali was for boxing, like <Morphy>, Steinitz or <Fischer> for chess.> Champions who don't play? Chess deserves better than that.
|
|
| | May-15-13 Karjakin vs Nakamura, 2013 
| |
|
keypusher: Carlsen: "c4 next, and then no earthly power can stop the a-pawn"
|
|
| | May-15-13 Carlsen vs Radjabov, 2013 
| |
|
keypusher: <SirRuthless> <Beating the bottom tablers and draw the stronger players is a good strategy.> Evidently Karjakin is employing the same strategy, since he's hammering Nakamura.
|
|
| | May-14-13 Women Grand Prix Geneva (2013) 
| |
|
keypusher: <John Abraham: <dx9293> Nonsense. The skills that are necessary to achieve a high level in chess (such as concentration, discipline, and abstract thinking) can be applied to other pursuits as well. Bobby Fischer once said, "I do not consider myself a chess genius, but a ...
|
|
| | May-14-13 Anand vs Karjakin, 2013 
| |
|
keypusher: It's like we've moved back 100 years in the Ruy Lopez recently.
|
|
| | May-10-13 Tamaz Gelashvili  May-10-13 Nigel Short  May-10-13 Wesley So  May-08-13 Magnus Carlsen  May-08-13 Fischer vs Fine, 1963  May-07-13 Norway Chess Tournament (Blitz) (2013)  May-07-13 Jeremy Lim  May-06-13 Duke Karl of Brunswick vs Prince of Villafranca, 1870  May-06-13 Gary Senior May-05-13 World Championship Candidates (2013)  May-05-13 Robert James Fischer  May-03-13 Fischer vs Larsen, 1971  May-03-13 Phony Benoni chessforum  May-02-13 Larsen vs Fischer, 1962 May-02-13 K Treybal vs Nimzowitsch, 1926 May-02-13 Veselin Topalov  May-01-13 FIDE Grand Prix Zug (2013)  May-01-13 Alekhine Memorial (2013)  May-01-13 Fischer vs Panno, 1970  Apr-30-13 E Pospisilova vs I Kopecek, 1968 Apr-30-13 Topalov vs Karjakin, 2013  Apr-29-13 Odd Lie  Apr-29-13 H P Garcia vs P Gelpke, 1983  Apr-28-13 Aronian vs Adams, 2013  Apr-26-13 Kibitzer's Café  Apr-25-13 Kramnik vs Fressinet, 2013  Apr-25-13 Lokvenc vs O Trinks, 1925 Apr-25-13 Ding Liren vs Aronian, 2013  Apr-24-13 Kasimdzhanov vs Nakamura, 2013  Apr-24-13 S Atalik vs B Baum, 1998  Apr-24-13 Radjabov vs Topalov, 2013  Apr-23-13 Chinese Championships (2013)  Apr-23-13 Topalov vs Nakamura, 2013  Apr-22-13 Tal vs Botvinnik, 1961 Apr-22-13 Glenn Redhead  Apr-18-13 M Walter vs Lasker, 1923 Apr-18-13 Fischer-Petrosian Candidates Match (1971)  Apr-17-13 Fischer-Spassky (1992)  Apr-16-13 Philidor vs Cotter, 1789  Apr-16-13 Taimanov vs Botvinnik, 1953 Apr-15-13 Emanuel Lasker  Apr-13-13 London (1899) Apr-09-13 Spassky vs Petrosian, 1966 Apr-09-13 Mieses vs M Kann, 1885 Apr-09-13 USSR Championship (1950) Apr-09-13 Samuel Newham  Apr-08-13 Vladimir Kramnik  Apr-06-13 Chigorin vs Rubinstein, 1907 Apr-06-13 H E Atkins vs W Schwan, 1899  Apr-06-13 Christiansen vs Karpov, 1993  Apr-05-13 Mikhail Botvinnik  Apr-03-13 Tal vs Petrosian, 1959  Apr-03-13 Vassily Ivanchuk  Apr-02-13 Carlsen vs Ivanchuk, 2013  Apr-01-13 keypusher chessforum  Apr-01-13 Ivanchuk vs Kramnik, 2013  Apr-01-13 Carlsen vs Svidler, 2013  Mar-31-13 Radjabov vs Carlsen, 2013  Mar-31-13 Grischuk vs Kramnik, 2013  Mar-30-13 Kramnik vs Gelfand, 2013  Mar-30-13 Ulf Andersson vs M Basman, 1974  Mar-29-13 S Novikov vs G Newerovski, 2005  Mar-28-13 Svidler vs Aronian, 2013  Mar-28-13 Grischuk vs Carlsen, 2013  Mar-26-13 Anastazia Karlovich  Mar-25-13 O Bender vs D Benge, 1962  Mar-25-13 Gelfand vs Aronian, 2013  Mar-24-13 Carlsen vs Aronian, 2013  Mar-23-13 Carlsen vs Grischuk, 2013  Mar-23-13 Carlsen vs Radjabov, 2013  Mar-16-13 Carlsen vs Kramnik, 2013  Mar-16-13 Averbakh vs Purdy, 1960  Mar-15-13 Aronian vs Carlsen, 2013  Mar-14-13 Spassky vs Fischer, 1972  Mar-14-13 Kramnik vs Carlsen, 2011  Mar-12-13 Jose Raul Capablanca  Mar-07-13 F Papastathi vs O Nikolopoulos, 2001  Mar-05-13 M Muzychuk vs P Rout, 2013 Mar-04-13 Garry Kasparov  Mar-01-13 Znosko-Borovsky vs E Cohn, 1909 Feb-28-13 Chigorin vs Lasker, 1897  Feb-27-13 Tal vs Botvinnik, 1961 Feb-27-13 Lasker vs Blackburne, 1892 Feb-27-13 Morozevich vs M Vachier-Lagrave, 2009  Feb-27-13 Lasker vs Blackburne, 1892  Feb-27-13 Reykjavik Open (2013)  Feb-26-13 Zurich Chess Challenge (2013)  Feb-26-13 Anna Ushenina  Feb-26-13 Elliott Forry Laucks  Feb-26-13 London (1851)  Feb-25-13 Anand vs Gelfand, 2013  Feb-24-13 Kasparov-Karpov World Championship Match (1987)  Feb-24-13 Tal vs Botvinnik, 1961 Feb-22-13 Karpov vs Stein, 1971  Feb-22-13 Botvinnik vs Tal, 1961 Feb-21-13 Y Yu vs Y Shulman, 2013 Feb-21-13 Lou Yiping vs Y Yu, 2013  Feb-20-13 Miles vs Plaskett, 1983  Feb-19-13 Aeroflot Rapid Open (2013)  Feb-15-13 F Bindrich vs D Fridman, 2010 Feb-15-13 GRENKE Chess Classic (2013)  Feb-15-13 Alexander Alekhine  Feb-14-13 D Fridman vs Naiditsch, 2013  Feb-14-13 Caruana vs Anand, 2013  Feb-13-13 Biographer Bistro  Feb-13-13 Daniel Freeman  Feb-12-13 Rubinstein vs Lasker, 1909  Feb-10-13 Botvinnik vs Tal, 1961  Feb-08-13 C Lolli vs D Ercole Del Rio, 1755  Feb-08-13 Bronstein vs Botvinnik, 1952 Feb-08-13 Botvinnik vs Tal, 1961 Feb-08-13 Tal vs Botvinnik, 1961 Feb-07-13 R Kola Feb-05-13 Carlsen vs Nakamura, 2013  Feb-05-13 Botvinnik vs R Mongredien, 1967  Feb-04-13 Tata Steel (2013)  Feb-03-13 Botvinnik vs Tal, 1961  Feb-02-13 Botvinnik vs Tal, 1961 Feb-02-13 USSR Championship (1945)  Jan-31-13 Reshevsky vs Fischer, 1966  Jan-30-13 Capablanca vs Kevitz, 1924 Jan-29-13 Baden Baden (1925)  Jan-29-13 chessgames.com chessforum  Jan-26-13 Alistair Compton  Jan-26-13 Hikaru Nakamura  Jan-25-13 Yifan Hou vs Anand, 2013  Jan-24-13 V Ciocaltea vs Fischer, 1965 Jan-23-13 Kasparov vs Portisch, 1983  Jan-22-13 TheFocus chessforum  Jan-22-13 W Shinkman vs T Thompson, 1875  Jan-22-13 Yifan Hou vs Carlsen, 2013  Jan-22-13 Cochrane vs Mohishunder, 1854  Jan-18-13 Carlsen vs I Sokolov, 2013  Jan-17-13 Lasker vs Burn, 1889  Jan-17-13 Harikrishna vs Van Wely, 2013  Jan-17-13 Anand vs Carlsen, 2013  Jan-16-13 Kashdan vs Reshevsky, 1932  Jan-15-13 Wang Hao vs Yifan Hou, 2013  Jan-14-13 Carlsen vs Van Wely, 2013  Jan-11-13 Samuel Reshevsky  Jan-09-13 Velimirovic vs A Zontakh, 1998  Dec-21-12 Kotov vs Keres, 1950  Dec-17-12 SportAccord World Mind Games (Men's Rapid) (2012)  Dec-14-12 Lasker vs P Romanovsky, 1925 Dec-13-12 Lasker vs E Delmar, 1892  Dec-11-12 H Wimmer vs A Caoili, 1998  Dec-10-12 London Chess Classic (2012)  Dec-10-12 Carlsen vs Anand, 2012  Dec-09-12 Kramnik vs G Jones, 2012  Dec-08-12 Adams vs McShane, 2012  Dec-08-12 Nakamura vs Carlsen, 2012  Dec-07-12 Carlsen vs Judit Polgar, 2012  Dec-07-12 Kramnik vs Carlsen, 2012  Dec-07-12 Emms vs J C Hawksworth, 1986 Dec-06-12 Efim Bogoljubov  Dec-06-12 Adams vs Carlsen, 2012  Dec-06-12 Karpov-Korchnoi World Championship Match (1978)  Dec-05-12 St Petersburg (1914)  Dec-05-12 J F Barry vs Pillsbury, 1899  Dec-04-12 Carlsen vs G Jones, 2012  Dec-02-12 Carlsen vs Aronian, 2012  Dec-02-12 McShane vs Carlsen, 2012  Nov-30-12 Keres vs Hug, 1973  Nov-19-12 Alekhine vs Capablanca, 1927  Nov-15-12 Botvinnik vs Fischer, 1962  Nov-09-12 J Peters vs Seirawan, 1984 Nov-09-12 Marshall vs Tartakower, 1930  Nov-09-12 St. Petersburg 1895-96 (1895) Nov-08-12 David Moody  Nov-06-12 Fischer vs Myagmarsuren, 1967  Nov-06-12 P Petrowitsch vs C Orpinas, 1993  Nov-05-12 D Sheppard vs R Fischer, 1995  Nov-02-12 Karpov-Fischer World Championship Match (1975)  Nov-01-12 SPICE Cup (2012)  Oct-25-12 Yifan Hou vs Nakamura, 2012  Oct-23-12 Nakamura vs Yifan Hou, 2012  Oct-22-12 J Rowson vs A Ledger, 1995  Oct-18-12 Plachetka vs L Zinn, 1974  Oct-18-12 Keres vs Fischer, 1959  Oct-17-12 Bilbao Masters (2012)  Oct-12-12 Carlsen vs Anand, 2012  Oct-11-12 Anand vs Caruana, 2012  Oct-09-12 Caruana vs Karjakin, 2012  Oct-08-12 Ernesto Ché Guevara  Oct-08-12 R Wojtaszek vs Ponomariov, 2012  Oct-08-12 Carlsen vs Caruana, 2012  Oct-03-12 Louis F Stumpers  Oct-02-12 Hector vs M Antonsen, 2010  Oct-02-12 Marmaduke Wyvill  Oct-01-12 Hirschfeld vs Anderssen, 1860 Sep-26-12 Vallejo-Pons vs Carlsen, 2012  Sep-25-12 Karjakin vs Caruana, 2012  Sep-25-12 FIDE Grand Prix London (2012)  Sep-21-12 Botvinnik vs J Penrose, 1962  Sep-21-12 B Andersson vs Botvinnik, 1962 Sep-21-12 Seirawan vs J Benjamin, 1989  Sep-21-12 Botvinnik vs A Pomar-Salamanca, 1962 Sep-14-12 S Atalik vs Nisipeanu, 2012  Sep-12-12 Paul Keres  Sep-11-12 M Hawelko vs Blatny, 1990  Sep-11-12 Kasparov vs S Thomson, 2003 Sep-10-12 Chess Olympiad (2012)  Sep-07-12 Karpov vs Miles, 1980  Sep-03-12 McDonnell vs La Bourdonnais, 1834  Aug-24-12 Boris Spassky  Aug-24-12 Keres vs W Winter, 1935 Aug-23-12 R Byrne vs Fischer, 1967  Aug-22-12 Chigorin vs F J Lee, 1899 Aug-17-12 Spassky vs Karpov, 1982  Aug-17-12 Hans-Joachim Federer  Aug-17-12 H E Atkins vs W Meiners, 1899  Aug-16-12 Fischer vs Spassky, 1972  Aug-14-12 Svetozar Gligoric  Aug-13-12 Fischer vs O Celle, 1964  Aug-09-12 F J Lee vs Lasker, 1899  Aug-07-12 N Kosintseva vs T Kosintseva, 2012  Aug-02-12 World Blitz Championship (2012)  Jul-31-12 Biel Chess Festival (2012)  Jul-26-12 Spassky vs Fischer, 1972  Jul-26-12 A Giri vs Bacrot, 2012  Jul-25-12 Znosko-Borovsky vs L Forgacs, 1907  Jul-14-12 Anand-Gelfand World Chess Championship (2012)  Jul-14-12 Maroczy vs Spielmann, 1908  Jul-13-12 Maroczy vs Spielmann, 1907 Jul-12-12 Unzicker vs M Czerniak, 1954  Jul-11-12 Paul Morphy  Jul-10-12 Botvinnik vs Vidmar, 1936  Jul-08-12 Alekhine-Bogoljubov World Championship Match (1929)  Jul-08-12 Tartakower vs H Wolf, 1907  Jul-06-12 Geller vs Bronstein, 1953  Jul-06-12 Judit Polgar vs Svidler, 2005  Jul-05-12 Karpov vs Spassky, 1974  Jul-02-12 Petrosian vs Fischer, 1970  Jun-30-12 Tartakower vs Maroczy, 1907  Jun-29-12 Flohr vs Botvinnik, 1933 Jun-29-12 Smyslov vs E Jimenez Zerquera, 1965  Jun-26-12 James Swain Mucklow  Jun-21-12 P Moran vs E Franco, 1955  Jun-20-12 Grischuk vs Nakamura, 2012  Jun-19-12 Pillsbury vs M Judd, 1898  Jun-19-12 Yifan Hou vs A Stefanova, 2012 Jun-19-12 Tal Memorial (2012)  Jun-16-12 Carlsen vs E Tomashevsky, 2012  Jun-15-12 Petrosian vs Portisch, 1974  Jun-13-12 Kan vs Capablanca, 1936  Jun-13-12 Radjabov vs Carlsen, 2012  Jun-12-12 Keres vs Filip, 1956 Jun-12-12 Viktor Korchnoi  Jun-10-12 Caruana vs Nakamura, 2012  Jun-09-12 Morozevich vs Carlsen, 2012  Jun-04-12 Karpov-Timman FIDE World Championship (1993)  May-31-12 Gelfand vs Eljanov, 2009  May-28-12 Anand vs Gelfand, 2012  May-16-12 Ljubojevic vs Ulf Andersson, 1976 May-09-12 Robson vs Kamsky, 2012  May-09-12 Nakamura vs R Hess, 2012  Apr-27-12 Morphy vs A Meek, 1857  Apr-26-12 Borin Topic  Apr-23-12 Janowski vs Lasker, 1896 Apr-20-12 Anderssen vs Morphy, 1858 Apr-19-12 Bronstein vs Benko, 1969  Apr-14-12 Robert Lee Hess  Apr-09-12 Tal vs Kavalek, 1979 Apr-06-12 Scott Thomson  Apr-06-12 Kolisch vs C W Vitzthum von Eckstaedt, 1859 Apr-05-12 crawfb5 chessforum  Apr-05-12 King's Gambit Accepted (C33)  Mar-22-12 Wilhelm Steinitz  Mar-19-12 Christiansen vs R Hess, 2011  Mar-17-12 Vitacek vs Duras, 1900  Mar-15-12 David Bronstein  Mar-12-12 Anderssen vs Blackburne, 1862  Mar-06-12 Vidmar vs Przepiorka, 1906  Feb-26-12 Kupchik vs Capablanca, 1918  Feb-26-12 Karpov vs Spassky, 1973  Feb-23-12 Krum Georgiev vs Kasparov, 1980  Feb-22-12 Spielmann vs Nimzowitsch, 1931 Feb-22-12 Pillsbury vs Tarrasch, 1895  Feb-16-12 Bronstein vs Browne, 1990  Feb-16-12 Flohr vs O Naegeli, 1933 Feb-16-12 Lev Alburt  Feb-13-12 J Mortimer vs J Mason, 1887  Feb-11-12 Pillsbury vs Albin, 1895 Feb-07-12 Capablanca vs Tartakower, 1938  Feb-03-12 Bogoljubov vs Nimzowitsch, 1920  Feb-02-12 Mieses vs Nimzowitsch, 1907  Feb-01-12 Anderssen vs Steinitz, 1866  Jan-28-12 Steinitz-Zukertort World Championship Match (1886)  Jan-26-12 Aron Nimzowitsch  Jan-25-12 Tal vs Spassky, 1965  Jan-24-12 Carlsen vs V Gashimov, 2012  Jan-23-12 Tata Steel (2012)  Jan-23-12 Petrosian vs Mecking, 1971  Jan-16-12 Harry Nelson Pillsbury  Jan-13-12 Raymond Keene  Jan-12-12 J O H Taylor vs Steinitz, 1865  Jan-11-12 Lasker vs A Ettlinger, 1893 Jan-10-12 Fischer vs O Neikirch, 1958  Jan-10-12 Ivanchuk vs Nakamura, 2012  Jan-06-12 Lisitsin vs Botvinnik, 1933 Dec-25-11 Christiansen vs Seirawan, 1978  Dec-23-11 Johann Hermann Bauer Dec-22-11 B Chesney vs Gulko, 1986  Dec-22-11 P Brandts vs Fischer, 1971  Dec-21-11 De Riviere vs Morphy, 1863  Dec-21-11 W Winter vs Lasker, 1936  Dec-21-11 Judit Polgar vs Kasparov, 2002  Dec-20-11 J H Donner vs Botvinnik, 1967  Dec-12-11 London Chess Classic (2011)  Dec-11-11 McShane vs Kramnik, 2011  Dec-11-11 Luke McShane  Dec-10-11 Carlsen vs Adams, 2011  Dec-10-11 A Artidiello vs D Freeman, 2001  Dec-09-11 Snowdrops and Old-hands (2011)  Dec-09-11 McShane vs Nakamura, 2011  Dec-09-11 Anthony Santasiere  Dec-09-11 Kasparov vs Speelman, 1989  Dec-08-11 Aronian vs Carlsen, 2011  Dec-06-11 Carlsen vs Kramnik, 2011  Dec-06-11 Carlsen vs Nakamura, 2011  Dec-06-11 Keres vs Botvinnik, 1948  Dec-05-11 Petrosian vs Larsen, 1965  Dec-04-11 Morphy vs Maurian, 1866  Dec-04-11 Carlsen vs D Howell, 2011  Nov-29-11 A K Robinson vs Lasker, 1892  Nov-28-11 Korchnoi vs Karpov, 1974  Nov-25-11 Nakamura vs Carlsen, 2011  Nov-23-11 Yifan Hou vs Koneru, 2011  Nov-23-11 Tony Palmer  Nov-22-11 Tal Memorial (2011)  Nov-22-11 Carlsen vs Svidler, 2011  Nov-20-11 James Kulbacki  Nov-20-11 Ivanchuk vs Carlsen, 2011  Nov-16-11 Mikhail Tal  Nov-08-11 Ftacnik vs Vallejo-Pons, 2007  Nov-06-11 Nakamura vs Aronian, 2011  Nov-03-11 Zukertort vs Blackburne, 1883  Oct-28-11 Samuel Schweber  Oct-26-11 Feuerstein vs Bennett, 1955  Oct-21-11 Von Popiel vs Tarrasch, 1896 Oct-07-11 Vallejo-Pons vs Ivanchuk, 2011  Oct-06-11 4th Bilbao Masters (2011)  Oct-03-11 John Cochrane  Sep-30-11 C H Alexander vs Botvinnik, 1936  Sep-29-11 Kmoch vs Rubinstein, 1926  Sep-28-11 Carlos Torre vs F E Parker, 1924  Sep-24-11 twinlark chessforum  Sep-21-11 Kasparov vs M Vachier-Lagrave, 2011  Sep-16-11 Seirawan vs A J Mestel, 1982  Sep-06-11 Botvinnik vs Kan, 1952  Sep-05-11 Judit Polgar  Sep-04-11 Aronian vs Anand, 2011  Sep-03-11 Karpov-Kasparov World Championship Match (1984)  Sep-03-11 Mecking vs Botvinnik, 1967  Sep-02-11 jww chessforum  Sep-01-11 Anatoly Karpov  Sep-01-11 Spassky vs Bronstein, 1960  Sep-01-11 Carl Schlechter  Aug-31-11 Anderssen vs Dufresne, 1852  Aug-31-11 Karpov vs Kasparov, 1984  Aug-30-11 T Kobe  Aug-24-11 Wolfgang Uhlmann  Aug-23-11 Tartakower vs Vidmar, 1907  Jul-31-11 Kramnik vs Nakamura, 2011  Jul-30-11 Reshevsky vs S Tatai, 1973  Jul-29-11 Gruenfeld vs L Asztalos, 1918  Jul-29-11 Ponomariov vs Nakamura, 2011  Jul-29-11 Dortmund (2011)  Jul-29-11 Edward Winter  Jul-29-11 Caruana vs Carlsen, 2011  Jul-28-11 Carlsen vs M Vachier-Lagrave, 2011  Jul-27-11 D Bowman vs D F Wilson, 1947  Jul-27-11 M Vachier-Lagrave vs Pelletier, 2011  Jul-26-11 Botvinnik vs Spielmann, 1935  Jul-26-11 Morozevich vs M Vachier-Lagrave, 2011  Jul-26-11 Shirov vs Carlsen, 2011  Jul-26-11 Mulyar vs Van Wely, 2011  Jul-25-11 Seirawan vs Mamedyarov, 2011  Jul-25-11 Kramnik vs A Giri, 2011  Jul-24-11 Nakamura vs Kramnik, 2011  Jul-23-11 M Vachier-Lagrave vs Carlsen, 2011  Jul-22-11 Carlsen vs Caruana, 2011  Jul-22-11 Stuart Brammall vs R Gashgarian, 2011 Jul-22-11 G Meier vs Kramnik, 2011  Jul-22-11 Botvinnik vs Pachman, 1947  Jul-22-11 P Popovic vs Seirawan, 1987  Jul-21-11 A Giri vs Nakamura, 2011  Jul-20-11 Karpov vs Seirawan, 1982  Jul-18-11 Smyslov vs Botvinnik, 1948  Jul-14-11 John Healy 
indicates a reply to the comment. | |